Gough Whitlam

Grattan on Friday: Albanese has made a statement in choosing Sam Mostyn as governor-general, but he could have been bolder

Retrieved on: 
星期五, 四月 5, 2024

Mostyn has progressive political views and, historically and currently, links with Labor governments.

Key Points: 
  • Mostyn has progressive political views and, historically and currently, links with Labor governments.
  • She was a staffer to Paul Keating, and has headed Anthony Albanese’s Women’s Economic Equality Taskforce.
  • None of that makes her unsuitable to be governor-general, a post occupied with distinction by former ministers from both sides of politics.
  • Mostyn’s appointment reflects the two sides of Albanese’s political character – the cautious leader and the leader who wants to make a statement.
  • The bigger statement would have been to choose the first Indigenous governor-general – a strong positive gesture after the referendum’s loss.
  • Also, an Indigenous appointee might potentally have come under serious personal pressures, given the differing views among their own people.
  • If he wasn’t to go the Indigenous route, it was virtually certain Albanese would appoint a woman.
  • Mostyn also had the attraction of extensive commercial experience, bringing something new to the office.
  • When he appeared with Mostyn at Wednesday’s news conference, Albanese carefully ensured she faced no questions.


Michelle Grattan does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

Ping-pong diplomacy: Australian table tennis players return to China, five decades after historic tour

Retrieved on: 
星期五, 十月 27, 2023

Only weeks after the team’s headline-making tour, Australia’s then opposition leader, Gough Whitlam, led a delegation to Beijing promising to open diplomatic relations “when elected”.

Key Points: 
  • Only weeks after the team’s headline-making tour, Australia’s then opposition leader, Gough Whitlam, led a delegation to Beijing promising to open diplomatic relations “when elected”.
  • One was table tennis, one was basketball and one was volleyball.
  • One was table tennis, one was basketball and one was volleyball.

‘A crowd of 8,000 people’

  • A revolutionary who became one of China’s most revered statesmen, he advocated peaceful co-existence with the West and other nations.
  • The American team embarked on their tour first – setting the stage for then-President Richard Nixon’s famous visit to Beijing in 1972.
  • Paul Pinkewich had just turned 20 at the time of the visit, teammate Steve Knapp was only 18.
  • Our first match in Canton, now Guangzhou, I think it was a crowd of 8,000 people,” he recalls.
  • “Do you wear this hair because of your disagreement with society or because it is a style?” Knapp replied, “It is the fashion.”
  • “Can you believe, one table in the middle of the Capital Stadium [in Beijing] with 18,000 spectators, and that was just an amazing experience.
  • But they always let the woman win.” That woman was Anne Middleton, the other player on the 1971 tour, who has since passed away.
  • After the trip we were labelled as communists […] but we were interested in friendship first, competition second.”

Why sport diplomacy matters

  • Beijing has continued to use sport as a diplomatic tool, including becoming the first city in the world to host both a summer and winter Olympic Games (Beijing in 2008 and 2022).
  • French educator Baron Pierre de Coubertin founded the International Olympic Committee in 1894, believing Olympics were a global event.
  • A new term has also emerged in recent years – almost always applied by researchers in democratic nations – to describe undemocratic nations’ forays into global sport: sportswashing.
  • “Amity between people holds the key to sound relations between countries.” At the heart of such amity, sport continues to play a significant role.


Tracey Holmes was one of the fifty Australians interviewed in the 'Fifty People, Fifty Stories' book due to her experiences of previously living and working in China.

Grattan on Friday: Cost-of-living crisis is the dragon the government can't slay

Retrieved on: 
星期四, 十月 26, 2023

No, she said, highlighting the importance of alliances and reassuring that the president could handle more than one thing at a time.

Key Points: 
  • No, she said, highlighting the importance of alliances and reassuring that the president could handle more than one thing at a time.
  • Of course, when an Australian prime minister is invited to Washington, he or she has to go.
  • The bank is usually Delphic about its intentions, and new governor Michele Bullock is showing herself a master at that game.
  • The board would receive more information before its meeting that would be important for this assessment, she said.
  • The point is, however, that whatever the government has done is for the average household only at the margin.
  • As the final treasurer in the Whitlam government, Hayden pursued budgetary rigour (in his case in the most difficult circumstances).
  • If it starts to consume the government’s support, it could eat a lot of political capital very quickly.


Michelle Grattan does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organization that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

A new biography of Donald Horne examines a life of indefatigable energy and intellectual curiosity

Retrieved on: 
星期四, 九月 7, 2023

Donald had written an essay called “Mind, body, age” that vigorously burst from the page with life, while addressing death.

Key Points: 
  • Donald had written an essay called “Mind, body, age” that vigorously burst from the page with life, while addressing death.
  • Being out of the loop, no longer an active participant in the cultural life of his beloved Sydney, hurt him.
  • In his accomplished and insightful biography Donald Horne: A Life in the Lucky Country, Ryan Cropp puts the man in his context and, without a heavy hand, helps us understand his motivating psychology.
  • Good biographies can be like that – Robert Caro is still finishing the biographical series on Lyndon Johnson he started 50 years ago.
  • Read more:
    Donald Horne's 'lucky country' and the decline of the public intellectual

The Lucky Country

    • Horne is best known as the author of The Lucky Country – a book that seemed to capture the zeitgeist when it was published, reluctantly, by Penguin in 1964.
    • The issues explored in The Lucky Country changed with new versions, but the critique remained: Australia got by on luck; it was held back by second-rate leaders who lacked vision, imagination and even a realistic assessment of its place in the world.
    • The Lucky Country, which owes more to his journalism than the more ambitiously polished writing in The Education of Young Donald, was a two-way mirror, revealing the nation to itself and him to it.
    • Read more:
      An armchair, a desk and 4000 books: the Horne family study gets a second life

Changing contexts

    • Cropp shows he has mastered the historian’s essential skill of avoiding this trap, while keeping the narrative moving with fresh and lively writing.
    • One striking contrast is between Horne’s confidence in Hayek’s wartime anti-bureaucratic, libertarian ethos, and Gough Whitlam’s rejection of it.
    • He was bored and wrote many letters to his mother (like so many others now preserved in archival boxes).
    • Times change, contexts shift, and responses by thoughtful people are recalibrated.

Intellectual tradition

    • His teachings and methods helped shape a Sydney intellectual tradition that still echoes today.
    • For those untouched by this tradition it was mystifying, but for those like Horne, Murray Sayle, Paddy McGuinness and many others, it provided an enduring framework that had the benefit of flexibility.
    • The cynical, libertarian realist became, by the late 1960s, more optimistic and more open to what Cropp characterises as “opportunities for civic renewal”.
    • The discipline of a biography, even one as grounded in public events as this, is that it demands a singular focus.

The cultural conversation

    • The coincidence of the publication of Horne’s Observer, funded by Frank Packer, and Tom Fitzgerald’s Nation in the late 1950s spoke to the need to aerate the national political and cultural conversation.
    • Cropp conveys a sense of this through the slightly limited prism of Horne’s worldview, with its emphasis on business, religion, Asia and politics.
    • Cropp has captured a full life, well lived, that was a tribute to the importance of paying attention and making a difference.

‘An extremely serious musical comedy’ about Whitlam? Yes. The Dismissal is great fun, witty and sharply observed

Retrieved on: 
星期三, 九月 6, 2023

While it lasted less than two full terms between December 1972 and November 1975, it has had an outsized cultural presence ever since.

Key Points: 
  • While it lasted less than two full terms between December 1972 and November 1975, it has had an outsized cultural presence ever since.
  • Each year since, we have marked the anniversary with new stories, new angles, new details.
  • The story has all the ingredients of high drama – indeed, the story was told in a rather ponderous television mini-series in 1983.
  • So almost 50 years on, what to make of a comedic musical retelling of these tumultuous events?

Self-referential and extremely funny

    • Playing Gough, Justin Smith both sounds and looks like him – no mean feat.
    • The Dismissal is least effective when it is striving for sincerity: the early number Maintain your Rage left me concerned the show might be too earnest to be genuinely funny.
    • It is self-referential and extremely funny and sets a high bar for the rest of the show.
    • His Private School Boys is a bump-and-grind showstopper that recalls Alexander Downer’s Freaky from Casey Benetto’s 2005 musical Keating!

Sharp, funny and astute

    • Margaret Whitlam (Brittanie Shipway) and Junie Morosi (Shannen Alyce Quan) are voices of reason and resolve.
    • Stacey Thomsett has much more fun with the role of Lady Kerr, who she depicts as Lady Macbeth in a Carla Zampatti suit.
    • But overall, The Dismissal is sharp, funny and astute.

How cartoonist Bruce Petty documented the Vietnam War – and how his great satire keeps finding its moment

Retrieved on: 
星期一, 八月 28, 2023

His career as a political cartoonist started with a trip to London in the late 1950s, then a stint at young Rupert Murdoch’s afternoon paper in Sydney, the Mirror.

Key Points: 
  • His career as a political cartoonist started with a trip to London in the late 1950s, then a stint at young Rupert Murdoch’s afternoon paper in Sydney, the Mirror.
  • He had a lead role as The Australian’s political cartoonist during the newspaper’s radical first decade, until it turned right during the Whitlam dismissal and Larry Pickering was promoted to favoured cartoonist.
  • Petty then moved to The Age in its glory days, where he was the acknowledged godfather of the troupe of brilliant cartoonists there at the time.

In the vanguard

    • Among them are these five particularly vivid cartoons published in The Australian between May 1966 and September 1967.
    • Petty was in the vanguard of a small but vocal opposition, drawing the war as a deep tragedy for the Vietnamese and a reckless farce perpetrated by the West.
    • The jagged black blob, which covers about half of the box, colours the movement from farce to tragedy arrestingly black.
    • Are Johnson and his adipose generals conscious villains, or merely fools being driven by murderous ideas and scarcely sublimated self-interest?

Intimate sympathy

    • Is this the moral fecklessness of consumer society projected onto women, or is it the dawn of concern for the people ravaged by a needless imperial war?
    • A large part of the power of these cartoons comes from Petty’s deep engagement with people forced to live with the war.
    • His first book, Australian Artist in South East Asia (1962), is a graphic account of his journey through seven countries.
    • – but he is doing it with an intimate sympathy born of real knowledge.

Internet Archive's digital library has been found in breach of copyright. The decision has some important implications

Retrieved on: 
星期三, 八月 23, 2023

The Internet Archive was founded in 1996 as a non-profit digital library, aiming to provide “universal access to all knowledge”.

Key Points: 
  • The Internet Archive was founded in 1996 as a non-profit digital library, aiming to provide “universal access to all knowledge”.
  • It started with a project to preserve the World Wide Web.
  • Since 2006, it has also provided a web archiving subscription service to institutions and individuals, allowing them to create digital archives and preserve collections of digital content.

Copyright issues

    • The lending of books that are out of copyright is not controversial, but Internet Archive’s distribution of copyrighted works is problematic.
    • Only one person can borrow any given copy at a time for a limited period.
    • Facilitating access to books in this manner without permission from, or payment to, publishers or authors has been condemned as a “flagrant violation of copyright and authors’ rights”.

Legal implications

    • The Southern District of New York court issued its final order in Hachette v. Internet Archive on March 24, 2023.
    • The consent judgement of August 11 has banned the Open Library from scanning or distributing commercially available books in digital formats.
    • This decision leaves a concerning gap: it does not apply to physical books that are not currently available digitally.
    • For example, authors of out-of-print works may choose to later publish their work in an ebook format and monetise that edition.

Consequences

    • Other libraries in Canada and the US have adopted the practice as an alternative to far more expensive and restrictive ebook licensing.
    • Though the Internet Archive is based in the US, its activities have an effect on the earnings of authors in Australia.
    • In contrast to Canada and the US, controlled digital lending is, in general, not allowed in Australia.
    • If we want authors to survive, we’ve got to stop assuming that authors’ intellectual labour is a public commodity.

How a secret plan 50 years ago changed Australia's economy forever, in just one night

Retrieved on: 
星期一, 七月 17, 2023

At a time when governments are timid, keener to announce reviews than decisions, it’s refreshing to remember what happened 50 years ago today – on July 18 1973.

Key Points: 
  • At a time when governments are timid, keener to announce reviews than decisions, it’s refreshing to remember what happened 50 years ago today – on July 18 1973.
  • Australia’s biggest customer, the United Kingdom, had joined the European Economic Community, agreeing to buy products from it rather than Australia.

Every tariff cut by one quarter overnight

    • As Whitlam put it: “each tariff will be reduced by one quarter of what it is now”.
    • If Australian businesses (and the Australian public) were caught by surprise, it was because Whitlam had planned the whole thing in secret.

Outsiders, not treasury insiders

    • Ttey were also good for government – bringing in tax revenue.
    • have a salutary effect upon those who have taken advantage of shortages by unjustified price increases which have exploited the public.
    • should not provide relief as a matter of course – that is, simply because the question of relief had been referred to it.
    • Over the next seven years, manufacturing employment fell by 80,000, but few of those job losses were immediate.
    • more importantly, we seriously doubt that the previous government would have had the wisdom or the courage to undertake it.

Author, ambassador, commentator, critic? It's not always easy to earn a crust as a former PM

Retrieved on: 
星期三, 七月 12, 2023

Few Australians are losing sleep over how Scott Morrison is going to earn a crust after politics.

Key Points: 
  • Few Australians are losing sleep over how Scott Morrison is going to earn a crust after politics.
  • His continuing presence on the opposition backbench serves as a distraction from the present and reminder of the past.
  • Unfortunately, that past keeps intruding on the present – most recently, in the form of the robodebt royal commission report.
  • Leaving aside the independently wealthy Malcolm Turnbull, Morrison is the first prime minister originally elected to parliament under the post-2004 superannuation arrangements for politicians.
  • Of course, former prime ministers receive many other goodies, such as office facilities and free travel, but that does not earn them a living.
  • He has been shopping himself around and seems to imagine a future on the lecture circuit.
  • That is potentially a nice little earner for an ex-leader, as Tony Blair and Bill Clinton have shown.

Expensive dental care worsens inequality. Is it time for a Medicare-style 'Denticare' scheme?

Retrieved on: 
星期日, 七月 2, 2023

Private dental care is increasingly unaffordable, and millions of Australians go without the treatment they need.

Key Points: 
  • Private dental care is increasingly unaffordable, and millions of Australians go without the treatment they need.
  • The potentially avoidable costs to the health-care system and to people’s quality of life has led to increased pressure for a Medicare-style universal insurance scheme for dental care (Denticare) or the inclusion of dental care into Medicare.
  • Affordable and available dental care is crucial to addressing inequality in Australia.

Why wasn’t dental included in Medicare in the first place?

    • There is, however, little to no evidence on the extent to which the Whitlam government pushed for dental to be included or how much it was opposed by dentists.
    • It seems it was not on the agenda when Medicare was restored by the Hawke government.
    • Secondly, the provision of public dental health services – often linked to dental hospitals and dental schools – has long been seen (especially by Coalition governments) as the responsibility of states and territories.

A short history

    • This section gives the Commonwealth the power to legislate and fund these services but it’s not obligated to do so.
    • The Whitlam government was the first to provide national funding and direction to these state-based programs through the Australian School Dental Program.

The barriers to universal dental care

    • These figures don’t factor in the savings made to health-care costs due to preventable dental cavities and gum disease (estimated by the Australian Dental Association at $818 million per year) and reduced productivity.
    • The other approach is to reduce costs by limiting the number of people covered and/or the number and type of services covered.
    • Means testing access to Medicare Benefits Schedule items for dental care is risky; it could easily lead to means testing of access to other MBS items.

There’s more we can do

    • Researchers have described the Chronic Dental Disease Scheme (introduced by the Howard government) as as “the most expensive and controversial public dental policy in Australian history”.
    • As a 2012 analysis showed, it blew out its budget and did not result in dental health improvements.
    • It’s worth noting many of the preventive actions needed to address obesity (for example, encouraging breast feeding and limiting sugary beverages) will also improve dental health.
    • Read more:
      How to fill the gaps in Australia's dental health system