Student

Are race-conscious scholarships on their way out?

Retrieved on: 
星期二, 四月 23, 2024

The review comes after Dave Yost, the state’s attorney general, advised administrators in a call that using race as a factor to award funds may be unconstitutional.

Key Points: 
  • The review comes after Dave Yost, the state’s attorney general, advised administrators in a call that using race as a factor to award funds may be unconstitutional.
  • The day after the Supreme Court’s decision, he had signaled that schools should clamp down on race-conscious programs.
  • He warned that “disguised” race-conscious admissions policies are still race-conscious admissions policies.

Targeting racial criteria

  • Officials at the universities of Kentucky and Missouri eliminated consideration of race in scholarships and grants.
  • This raises a question that goes beyond Ohio: Are scholarships that use race as part of their criteria a thing of the past?
  • To figure that out, administrators may have to go back to the source: the 2023 Supreme Court decision.

Diversity and the ‘strict scrutiny’ test

  • In 2003 and again in 2016, the court ruled that a diverse student body is a compelling interest.
  • But in 2023, Harvard and UNC weren’t able to pass the strict scrutiny test.
  • But this overlooks two important facts: The Supreme Court did not rule that diversity can never be a compelling state interest or that race can never be considered.
  • Even race-conscious admissions aren’t completely off the table – if programs can pass the strict scrutiny test.
  • But after the Harvard and UNC decision, even these programs will need to explore other ways to achieve diversity.
  • MIT and Stanford Law are among the programs already using criteria such as income, ZIP code and civic engagement to maintain diversity.

More challenges ahead

  • In contrast, some campus leaders and lawyers argue that the court’s decision should be limited to race-conscious admissions.
  • They argue it should not include other programs where race might be used as a factor.

Tips for prospective students and their parents

  • Students can also take the following steps: • Stay informed: Follow the news to find out whether changes in state laws or policies will affect scholarship opportunities.
  • • Talk to financial aid administrators: Connect with advisers in the school’s financial aid office to learn how they interpret the Harvard/UNC decision.


The authors do not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organization that would benefit from this article, and have disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

Academics with disabilities: South African universities need an overhaul to make them genuinely inclusive

Retrieved on: 
星期二, 四月 23, 2024

Very little research has been conducted about academics with disabilities working in South African universities. This means their stories, and the challenges they face in the daily demands of their jobs, are not often told. Sibonokuhle Ndlovu, who holds a PhD in education and lectures on the subject, explains what her study of academics with disabilities revealed. How many academics with disabilities are working in South Africa’s universities?There’s also not been much research about academics with disabilities in the country.

Key Points: 


Very little research has been conducted about academics with disabilities working in South African universities. This means their stories, and the challenges they face in the daily demands of their jobs, are not often told. Sibonokuhle Ndlovu, who holds a PhD in education and lectures on the subject, explains what her study of academics with disabilities revealed.

How many academics with disabilities are working in South Africa’s universities?

  • There’s also not been much research about academics with disabilities in the country.
  • And we do know that students with disabilities enrolled in South Africa’s institutions of higher education make up less than 1% of the student population.
  • In short, there are relatively few academics with disabilities.

What was the purpose of your study?

  • Most institutions’ lecture halls, toilets and libraries are not easily used by academics with disabilities.
  • Read more:
    Six challenges that impede entrepreneurs with disabilities in South Africa

    The second challenge relates to research.

  • Like all other academics in higher education, academics with disabilities are expected to conduct research as part of their work.
  • An academic who cannot see when required to use a small needle on a patient, for instance, will struggle to complete the task.
  • Higher education institutions should consider how to support academics in these areas, perhaps by providing research assistants.

Aren’t there policies to support academics with disabilities?

  • But there’s a big gap in the policy: it doesn’t consider different categories of disabilities.
  • Some universities have their own institutional disability policies, but I found over and over again in my research that students and academics with disabilities weren’t often invited to contribute.
  • The policies were made for them rather than with them, which resulted in policies that simply didn’t work.


Sibonokuhle Ndlovu previously received funding from the National Research Foundation, to conduct research in the disability field from 2020-2022..

She is currently affiliated to the University of Johannesburg, Ali Mazrui Centre

Saskatchewan recognized ASL and Indigenous sign languages as official languages — and resources are needed for services

Retrieved on: 
星期二, 四月 23, 2024

Saskatchewan recently became one of four Canadian provinces that recognize sign languages as official languages with the passing of the Accessible Saskatchewan Act or Bill 103 in December.

Key Points: 
  • Saskatchewan recently became one of four Canadian provinces that recognize sign languages as official languages with the passing of the Accessible Saskatchewan Act or Bill 103 in December.
  • The bill states, “Sign languages are recognized as the primary languages for communication by deaf persons in Saskatchewan,” including American Sign Language (ASL) and Indigenous sign languages.
  • Nationally, the Accessible Canada Act was passed in 2019 also recognizing ASL, Langue des signes du Québec and Indigenous sign languages in Canada.

Access to services, opportunities

  • A historic polarization between adherents of sign language and of auditory-verbal therapy (AVT) has hindered provision of educational services for DHH children.
  • Under the belief that sign language would hinder oral development, many DHH individuals were forbidden to learn sign language — an attitude which still lingers among some today.

Human Rights Commission findings

  • In a 2016 report, the Saskatchewan Human Rights Commission (SHRC) documented that some health professionals were telling parents to avoid sign language in favour of cochlear implants, lip reading and AVT to achieve spoken competence.
  • Adherents of sign languages argue in favour of giving children sign language instruction as early as possible.
  • The lack of language during critical periods of development, some argue, can lead to language deprivation syndrome, isolation and mental health issues.

Parents need full range of options

  • Regardless of good intentions on either side of the AVT versus ASL argument, the real need is to ensure DHH children can reach their developmental milestones.
  • In an interview, Robyn Holmes, president of the Saskatchewan Deaf Association, who is also an early childhood and family services specialist for Saskatchewan Deaf and Hard of Hearing Services, said that rather than an either-AVT-or-ASL approach, parents should have a full range of options and that “sign language as the ‘last’ option is not acceptable.” The SHRC also notes parents of DHH children should be provided with a full list of options.

Compounded systemic failings

  • In 2016, a case documented by the office of Saskatchewan’s Advocate for Children and Youth demonstrated how systemic failings in educational services are compounded for DHH Indigenous children and youth whose communities are drastically under-resourced.
  • The report details cascading failures at multiple levels including the lack of access to language, barriers to health services and other systemic, procedural and policy issues.

Resources for deaf learners


It remains to be seen how K-12 school divisions will respond to making public plans to accommodate deaf students in light of the Accessibility Act. Some resources for DHH learners in Saskatchewan are appearing. For example:
There is a provincial curriculum available to teach ASL and Deaf Culture for high school.
The Children, Communicating, Connecting in Community (CCCC) preschool was opened in 2018 in Saskatoon that offers full access to ASL and English. The preschool serves children who are deaf or hard of hearing and those who have connections to the Deaf community.
St. Philip, a Catholic School in Saskatoon, offers a bilingual/bicultural program for DHH students and Henry Janzen School in Regina offers educational services for DHH learners from pre-kindergarten to Grade 8.
People can take ASL classes and access DHH-related services at the Saskatchewan Deaf and Hard of Hearing Services (SDHHS).

Accessibility plans needed

  • Over the next two years, they must develop an accessibility plan that identifies, removes and prevents barriers.
  • The bill currently offers no guidelines for the kinds of services or level of accommodations that need to go into the accessibility plans.

Classroom considerations, technologies

  • Therefore, all teachers should have access to training in how to communicate with DHH students through both the ASL alphabet and basic conversational and classroom-related signs.
  • I have used FaceTime and the Video Relay Services (VRS) to communicate with deaf friends, colleagues and fellow learners.

Money, time and effort needed


Teacher training, as well as reviewing, selecting and preparing both digital and non-digital resources for classrooms and for school-DHH community communication will take money, time and effort. Educational institutions will require support and resources to ensure our publicly funded educational institutions can provide the appropriate services and learning technologies.
Marguerite Koole does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

Young people in Britain aren’t bad at learning languages – but the school system doesn’t make it easy for them

Retrieved on: 
星期二, 四月 23, 2024

But are the British really bad at learning foreign languages?

Key Points: 
  • But are the British really bad at learning foreign languages?
  • This comparatively short period of formal language learning is likely to have a substantial impact on language attainment amongst school leavers.
  • Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland have native languages which are taught both as second languages and through bilingual or immersion schooling.
  • UK students’ learning of these native languages shows that when given significant exposure to a language, they can achieve fluency.

Choosing to learn

  • Another factor to consider is why students learn languages, and how this affects their achievement.
  • There will certainly be young people who feel that language learning is something they have to do, rather than something they want to take part in.
  • However, other students are motivated to learn languages which they feel a personal connection to or see personal value in.
  • English has become a global lingua franca, and consequently Anglophones can feel like foreign language skills are less needed.
  • This also means that English language skills are a useful extra for many people around the world and allow them to get by in many countries – that’s a strong motivation to learn.
  • Read more:
    The UK is poorer without Erasmus – it's time to rejoin the European exchange programme

    There is no evidence that British young people have an inability to learn foreign languages.


Abigail Parrish does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

What doesn’t kill you makes for a great story – two new memoirs examine the risky side of life

Retrieved on: 
星期二, 四月 23, 2024

She questions whether women like herself – that is, the well-educated, sexually liberated beneficiaries of second-wave feminism – are really better off than their 1940s counterparts.

Key Points: 
  • She questions whether women like herself – that is, the well-educated, sexually liberated beneficiaries of second-wave feminism – are really better off than their 1940s counterparts.
  • But it isn’t quite the avant-garde art crowd looking for anonymous vaginas to cast in their latest 16mm masterpieces either.
  • Reconstructed from the travel diary the author kept at the time, the adventure is everything you could possibly hope for in a road trip – provided you (or your daughter) aren’t the one taking it.
  • Datsun Angel proves the old adage about time and tragedy making for champagne comedy.
  • It self-consciously situates itself as a cross between the substance-induced exuberance of Jack Kerouac and Hunter S. Thompson, and the provincially impassioned politics of Australian novelist Xavier Herbert.
  • For all her progressivism, there is a note of nostalgia ringing through Broinowski’s recollections.
  • Datsun Angel harks back to a looser – dare I say, more enjoyable – university experience.
  • The narrative promises, against well-intentioned assurances to the contrary, that what doesn’t kill you will, at the very least, make for a good story later on.
  • Broinowski goes part way towards acknowledging as much when she ends her postscript with: “If you’re male and reading this, kudos.

Detachment

  • Let me borrow one instead from the middle-aged Elmore Leonard fan whom Gordon encounters in the State Library Victoria early in the book: “dickhead”.
  • Yes, that about captures it: the protagonist of Excitable Boy is an unequivocal, grade-A dickhead.
  • Fortunately for Gordon (and dickheads more generally), the affliction may be chronic, but it need not be terminal.
  • This denotes an overriding structure or cohesion that I felt somewhat lacking from the work as a whole.
  • Detachment characterises much of Gordon’s storytelling as he kicks his younger self around the back alleys of Melbourne like a half-squashed can of Monster Energy Drink.
  • To be honest, I still haven’t made my mind up if Gordon’s aversion to Aristotelian catharsis is one of the book’s virtues or vices.
  • Detail has to be controlled by some overall purpose, and every detail has to be put to work for you.
  • Detail has to be controlled by some overall purpose, and every detail has to be put to work for you.
  • It is often difficult to gauge what overall purpose the details are serving in these essays, beyond fidelity to memory.


Luke Johnson does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

The UK is poorer without Erasmus – it’s time to rejoin the European exchange programme

Retrieved on: 
星期五, 四月 19, 2024

The United Kingdom’s withdrawal from the Erasmus+ scheme – a reciprocal exchange process that let UK students study at European universities, and European students come to the UK – is again under the spotlight.

Key Points: 
  • The United Kingdom’s withdrawal from the Erasmus+ scheme – a reciprocal exchange process that let UK students study at European universities, and European students come to the UK – is again under the spotlight.
  • The scope of the Turing scheme is more narrow, as it focuses on outbound mobility from the UK rather than reciprocal exchanges.
  • Participating in international exchange programmes offers a plethora of benefits, ranging from personal growth to academic enrichment and professional development.
  • I can attest to its profound role in shaping well-rounded individuals equipped with the skills to thrive in today’s interconnected world.

Benefits on both sides

  • There are many benefits enjoyed by students participating in international exchange programmes.
  • But welcoming international exchange students to UK campuses also offers huge advantages to universities and broader society.
  • International exchange students bring with them unique perspectives, skills and experiences that enrich the learning environment for everyone.
  • Language learning and international mobility go hand in hand in fostering essential qualities such as curiosity, empathy and effective communication.

Halting decline

  • The ongoing decline in language learning in the UK is concerning.
  • Academics and teachers are trying to address this and have been creating initiatives to re-think how we approach language teaching.
  • To truly ensure equitable access to language learning, further investment is needed, coupled with a renewed commitment to international mobility.


Sascha Stollhans is affiliated with the Linguistics in Modern Foreign Languages project. The related research mentioned in the article was funded by Language Acts and Worldmaking, part of the Arts and Humanities Research Council's Open World Research Initiative, an Impact Accelerator Grant from the University of Bristol and a Research Start-up Grant from the Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences, Newcastle University.

Are tomorrow’s engineers ready to face AI’s ethical challenges?

Retrieved on: 
星期五, 四月 19, 2024

A test version of a Roomba vacuum collects images of users in private situations.

Key Points: 
  • A test version of a Roomba vacuum collects images of users in private situations.
  • The general public depends on software engineers and computer scientists to ensure these technologies are created in a safe and ethical manner.
  • What’s more, some appear apathetic about the moral dilemmas their careers may bring – just as advances in AI intensify such dilemmas.

Aware, but unprepared

  • We asked students about their experiences with ethical challenges in engineering, their knowledge of ethical dilemmas in the field and how they would respond to scenarios in the future.
  • When asked, however, “Do you feel equipped to respond in concerning or unethical situations?” students often said no.
  • “Do YOU know who I’m supposed to go to?” Another was troubled by the lack of training: “I [would be] dealing with that with no experience.


Other researchers have similarly found that many engineering students do not feel satisfied with the ethics training they do receive. Common training usually emphasizes professional codes of conduct, rather than the complex socio-technical factors underlying ethical decision-making. Research suggests that even when presented with particular scenarios or case studies, engineering students often struggle to recognize ethical dilemmas.

‘A box to check off’

  • A study assessing undergraduate STEM curricula in the U.S. found that coverage of ethical issues varied greatly in terms of content, amount and how seriously it is presented.
  • Additionally, an analysis of academic literature about engineering education found that ethics is often considered nonessential training.
  • [Misusage] issues are not their concern.” One of us, Erin Cech, followed a cohort of 326 engineering students from four U.S. colleges.
  • Following them after they left college, we found that their concerns regarding ethics did not rebound once these new graduates entered the workforce.

Joining the work world

  • When engineers do receive ethics training as part of their degree, it seems to work.
  • Along with engineering professor Cynthia Finelli, we conducted a survey of over 500 employed engineers.
  • Over a quarter of these practicing engineers reported encountering a concerning ethical situation at work.
  • Yet approximately one-third said they have never received training in public welfare – not during their education, and not during their career.


Elana Goldenkoff receives funding from National Science Foundation and Schmidt Futures. Erin A. Cech receives funding from the National Science Foundation.

Hard work and happy accidents: why do so many of us prefer ‘difficult’ analogue technology?

Retrieved on: 
星期四, 四月 18, 2024

Up two flights of stairs, the music machinery on offer includes brands such as Moog and Buchla, as well as modern euro-racks.

Key Points: 
  • Up two flights of stairs, the music machinery on offer includes brands such as Moog and Buchla, as well as modern euro-racks.
  • (From Michael’s fieldnotes)
    I finally locate the legendary Schneiders Buero, a shop selling analogue synthesizers in Berlin’s Kotti neighbourhood.
  • Up two flights of stairs, the music machinery on offer includes brands such as Moog and Buchla, as well as modern euro-racks.
  • (From Michael’s fieldnotes) As academics who rarely go a day without playing or making music, we have spent the past decade examining the extraordinary revival of analogue technology.
  • This means there are now more analogue options available than at any time since the 1970s, the heyday of the modular format.

The appeal of the slow

  • So we dived in.
  • Eventually, these forays became our formal research project, which has included visiting record fairs and conventions around the world, going on photowalks and attending listening evenings, and meeting an array of diehard analogue communities both on and off line.
  • The team is working with academics from different backgrounds who have been engaged in projects aimed at tackling societal and scientific challenges.
  • And we expect interest in such experiences to rise exponentially in coming years.
  • Recognising our existential need to occasionally slow down can be the basis for winning consumer strategies.
  • Recognising our existential need to occasionally slow down can be the basis for winning consumer strategies.

Saved from demolition

  • Rather than nostalgia, they are turning to film because of its aesthetic values and a greater sense of creative control over their photos.
  • In response, venerable brands including Kodak, Polaroid and Leica have re-emerged – in some cases, almost from the dead.
  • We literally saved it from demolition at the very last second in 2008.
  • We literally saved it from demolition at the very last second in 2008.
  • He said luxury brands such as Gucci are particularly keen on using film photography as this gives their promotional material a different look.

Work, effort, meaning

  • When it was conceded that digital probably was better for wildlife photography, James cut in:
    That’s to miss the point!
  • The sound might be better but you miss seeing the work that went into the performance, the effort of the players and their crew.
  • Work, effort, meaning – these ideas are all interconnected for users and consumers of analogue technology.
  • However, when asked to compare the two, they talk about the greater weight and meaning they give to their analogue experiences.
  • I think it is the quality of the human voice; it does feel more like someone’s speaking to me.
  • And part of what makes this possible is the process of analogue recording, in which all the sounds being made, including the unscripted noise of the recording process itself, are captured in the final track.
  • To facilitate this sound, some musicians have even started setting up their own pressing plants, such as Jack White’s Third Man Pressing in Detroit.

The joy of happy accidents

  • Half of what you do trying to make music is like a happy accident that ends up sounding better than what you intended.
  • When we started, we didn’t have that technology, so we made mistakes and some of them were happy accidents, resulting in iconic tracks.
  • When we started, we didn’t have that technology, so we made mistakes and some of them were happy accidents, resulting in iconic tracks.
  • It’s these happy accidents that we love.
  • It’s these happy accidents that we love.
  • For example, the opening bass part of Cannonball, the 1993 song by US Indie band the Breeders, accidentally starts in a different key.
  • Bass player Josephine Wiggs began playing the riff one step down, then fixed it when the drums came in.

Digital technology is de-skilling us

  • Over the decade or so of our research, explanations for the analogue revival have shifted from nostalgia, to the desire for something physical in a digital age, to the sense that analogue technology is creatively preferable.
  • Is digital technology de-skilling consumers, leading to a sense of alienation?
  • Using analogue technology is another way consumers can feed this desire to re-skill.
  • Rob told us how his love of music had turned sour with the “sheer ease” of digital, starting with CDs and the MP3 player – and how vinyl had reinvigorated him.
  • For him, the problem came when listening on digital devices without the “sides” of vinyl albums, and then on music streaming platforms whose digital algorithms preference popular tracks.

‘This song sucks’

  • These are the people who want to stretch and break the rules and trigger the happy accidents that create something altogether new.
  • For example, photographers who seek more creative expressions by pre-soaking or “souping” their camera film in lemon juice, coffee, beer, or even burning it.
  • And among this group, connecting digital and analogue technology is also common – combining two completely different systems to generate even more possibilities.
  • Film director Denis Villeneuve’s first instalment of Dune (2021) was initially shot on digital, then transferred to film, before being re-digitised.
  • By combining the two, Villeneuve got a film that, in his words, has a “more timeless, painterly feel”.


For you: more from our Insights series:
How music heals us, even when it’s sad – by a neuroscientist leading a new study of musical therapy

The artist formerly known as Camille – Prince’s lost album ‘comes out’

Beatrix Potter’s famous tales are rooted in stories told by enslaved Africans – but she was very quiet about their origins

To hear about new Insights articles, join the hundreds of thousands of people who value The Conversation’s evidence-based news. Subscribe to our newsletter.
The authors do not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and have disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

Graduation rates for low-income students lag while their student loan debt soars

Retrieved on: 
星期四, 四月 18, 2024

Many start but don’t finish

Key Points: 
  • Many start but don’t finish
    The problem goes beyond the fact that students from lower-income households are entering higher education at a lower rate than high-income students.
  • One key factor is that low-income students of color tend to go to low-funded higher education institutions with low graduation rates.
  • The combination of low graduation rates and high debt can severely reduce the ability to pay off loans.
  • A significant part of student debt is generated by for-profit colleges that have low graduation rates.

Columbia president holds her own under congressional grilling over campus antisemitism that felled the leaders of Harvard and Penn

Retrieved on: 
星期四, 四月 18, 2024

Two of them resigned shortly thereafter.

Key Points: 
  • Two of them resigned shortly thereafter.
  • Here, Lynn Greenky, a scholar of communication and rhetoric, gives her take on how Shafik handled being in the same hot seat as her colleagues.

How did today’s hearing differ from the one on Dec. 5?

  • Of course, they had the benefit of being able to first see what happens when you don’t.
  • Shipman in particular made it clear that Columbia is suffering a “moral crisis” on its campus.
  • They even thanked the committee for the investigation and asked for the committee’s help to address antisemitism on campus.

What did committee members say about faculty?

  • Several members of the Congressional committee singled out Massad, who on Oct. 8, 2023, described the Hamas attack on Israel as “awesome” and “innovative” in an online article, for particular scorn.
  • The committee’s chairperson, Virginia Foxx, a Republican from West Virginia, warned that radical faculty remain a huge problem at Columbia.
  • If not, she says, Columbia will be brought before the committee again.

Was there any conflict over what is hate speech?

  • Shafik seemed reluctant to label students or faculty as engaging in hate and harassment.
  • She tried very hard, sometimes unsuccessfully, to assert the need to balance constitutionally protected speech with the educational mission of the university.
  • Still, Shafik frequently testified that the policies and structures in place at Columbia prior to the Oct. 7 attack were inadequate.

What action did Shafik and her colleagues say they would take?

  • They said they are working on revising policies and practices that will promote vigorous debate while protecting student safety.
  • As a result of some of the preliminary recommendations of Columbia’s Task Force on Antisemitism, the university has updated the reporting and response process regarding harassment and discrimination.

How will all this affect free speech on campus?

  • Certainly, a college or university has a compelling interest in protecting its students, faculty and staff’s freedom, safety and integrity.
  • Often, when colleges and universities undertake the task, I believe it is the freedom to speak one’s mind that suffers.


Lynn Greenky does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organization that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.