United Nations

AI chatbots refuse to produce ‘controversial’ output − why that’s a free speech problem

Retrieved on: 
星期四, 四月 18, 2024

Still, the conversation on AI ignores another crucial issue: What is the AI industry’s approach to free speech, and does it embrace international free speech standards?

Key Points: 
  • Still, the conversation on AI ignores another crucial issue: What is the AI industry’s approach to free speech, and does it embrace international free speech standards?
  • In practice, this means that AI chatbots often censor output when dealing with issues the companies deem controversial.
  • Without a solid culture of free speech, the companies producing generative AI tools are likely to continue to face backlash in these increasingly polarized times.

Vague and broad use policies

  • Companies issue policies to set the rules for how people can use their models.
  • With international human rights law as a benchmark, we found that companies’ misinformation and hate speech policies are too vague and expansive.
  • Our analysis found that companies’ hate speech policies contain extremely broad prohibitions.
  • To show how vague and broad use policies can affect users, we tested a range of prompts on controversial topics.
  • More recently, India confronted Google after Gemini noted that some experts consider the policies of the Indian prime minister, Narendra Modi, to be fascist.

Free speech culture

  • If they serve a global audience, they may want to avoid content that is offensive in any region.
  • This means society has an interest in ensuring such policies adequately protect free speech.
  • Even where a similar legal obligation does not apply to AI providers, we believe that the companies’ influence should require them to adopt a free speech culture.
  • At least two of the companies we focused on – Google and Anthropic – have recognized as much.

Outright refusals

  • Therefore, users’ exposure to hate speech and misinformation from generative AI will typically be limited unless they specifically seek it.
  • This is unlike social media, where people have much less control over their own feeds.
  • Stricter controls, including on AI-generated content, may be justified at the level of social media since they distribute content publicly.
  • Refusals to generate content not only affect fundamental rights to free speech and access to information.
  • The Future of Free Speech is a non-partisan, independent think tank that has received limited financial support from Google for specific projects.
  • In all cases, The Future of Free Speech retains full independence and final authority for its work, including research pursuits, methodology, analysis, conclusions, and presentation.
  • The Future of Free Speech is a non-partisan, independent think tank that has received limited financial support from Google for specific projects.

The Trial of Vladimir Putin: Geoffrey Robertson rehearses the scenarios

Retrieved on: 
星期四, 四月 18, 2024

In The Trial of Vladimir Putin, barrister Geoffrey Robertson answers that question by dramatising what might happen within the walls of a future courtroom.

Key Points: 
  • In The Trial of Vladimir Putin, barrister Geoffrey Robertson answers that question by dramatising what might happen within the walls of a future courtroom.
  • The question of whether Putin is guilty of aggression is fairly straightforward.
  • Evidence would be needed that he is responsible in his role as a commander for actions carried out by subordinates.
  • Instead, a special aggression tribunal would have to be established in the tradition of the trials of Nazis at Nuremberg.
  • It is not pure fiction; it is speculation informed by Robertson’s experience.
  • The details he imagines will bring these potential future trials to life for readers who are less familiar than he is with the inside of a courtroom.
  • Does Robertson really need to tell us three times that any judgements should be uploaded to the internet?

Rhetorical devices

  • Whether Putin should be tried even if absent is a hard question because there are arguments on both sides.
  • Instead, he uses rhetorical tools such as hyperbole: if “international law is to have any meaning”, he writes, then a trial in the defendant’s absence “must be acceptable”.
  • Robertson criticises this with the remark that it “entitles a man who has given orders to kill thousands to stand back and laugh”.
  • It is that he gives the impression that the complexities do not exist.
  • Dismissive language is a more general feature of his writing style.
  • The implication is that Robertson is atypical among lawyers, someone who will sweep aside conventions and assumptions.
  • Read more:
    An inside look at the dangerous, painstaking work of collecting evidence of suspected war crimes in Ukraine

The United Nations

  • One of the bolder elements in the book is what Robertson says about the United Nations.
  • One of them is that the Security Council could authorise, say, the United States to take military action against another nuclear-armed major power: is that outcome “obviously right”?
  • The same logic might be used to justify expelling the United States, Britain and Australia, which were accused of unlawfully invading Iraq in 2003.
  • Robertson compares the UN unfavourably with its predecessor, the League of Nations, which “expelled the USSR for attacking Finland”.


Rowan Nicholson does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

Earth Day: ‘Green muscle memory’ and climate education promote behaviour change

Retrieved on: 
星期四, 四月 18, 2024

This year, organizers of Earth Day are calling for widespread climate education as a critical step in the fight against climate change.

Key Points: 
  • This year, organizers of Earth Day are calling for widespread climate education as a critical step in the fight against climate change.
  • A new report, released in time for global attention for Earth Day on April 22, highlights the impact of climate education on promoting behaviour change in the next generation.

How knowledge becomes ingrained

  • Teachers have become increasingly concerned about best practices for supporting their charges as young people express anxiety about environmental futures.
  • Similarly, Finnish researchers use biking as an analogy to describe the process by which knowledge becomes ingrained in people’s memory.
  • The bike model advocates ways of learning that consider knowledge, identity, emotions and world views.
  • More than half of the survey respondents were from Ontario (25 per cent) and Québec (29 per cent).

Challenges with climate education

  • However, inclusion of climate education in formal school curricula has come with its own set of challenges.
  • Educators in Ontario reported a lack of classroom resources as a barrier when integrating climate change education within the curriculum.
  • The United Nations has declared climate education “a critical agent in addressing the issue of climate change” as climate education increases across different settings and for various age groups.

Educators finding ways

  • More and more educators are taking steps to find ways to teach climate education in schools.
  • As an instructor for several undergraduate-level courses, Olsen focuses on equipping budding educators with the skills and knowledge to incorporate climate education in their classrooms.

All aspects of curricula

  • Embedding climate education into all aspects of curricula can take a variety of approaches in and outside of the classroom.
  • Environmental education has been packaged in different forms, including broadening school curricula with inclusion in science, but also subjects including English, math and art.


Preety Sharma is a public health and development consultant. As a freelance journalist, she covers climate change, public health and nutrition. Ayeshah Haque is a Clinical Content Specialist at the Association for Ontario Midwives.

Shifts in how sex and gender identity are defined may alter human rights protections: Canadians deserve to know how and why

Retrieved on: 
星期三, 四月 10, 2024

Recent education policy changes and protests about sex education reveal increasing concern and polarization over how sex and gender identity are taught in public schools in Canada.

Key Points: 
  • Recent education policy changes and protests about sex education reveal increasing concern and polarization over how sex and gender identity are taught in public schools in Canada.
  • They also expose the significant role now played by school boards in constructing the meaning of gender identity and gender expression.
  • Changes in how words and terms are used can impact our ability to know about people’s lives and protect their rights.
  • Significant shifts are taking place around how we define and understand sex and gender in education and public policy in Canada.

Sex, gender and law

  • Yet sex, gender identity and gender expression are not defined in human rights legislation in Canada.
  • They should be able to express their concerns and participate in open discussions about the meaning of words we share.

Changes in the definition of sex

  • The Charter of the United Nations prohibits sex discrimination.
  • The United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights precludes discrimination based on sex.

Changes since 2018


Since 2018, the word sex is increasingly defined by the federal government as something that is “assigned at birth.” But there is no consistency across federal departments and agencies. Some continue to define sex as a biological question of male or female. Those that define sex as assigned at birth do not consistently explain how sex is assigned or by whom.

Conceptual shifts around word ‘woman’

  • Similar conceptual shifts are taking place around the word woman.
  • The word woman was formerly linked to sex and used to refer to female people.
  • Now, government departments including the Department of Justice increasingly use the word woman to refer to all people who identify as women.

Defining gender identity

  • When gender identity was added to federal human rights legislation, the Department of Justice defined gender identity as:
    “each person’s internal and individual experience of gender.
  • A person’s gender identity may or may not align with the gender typically associated with their sex.”
    “A person’s internal and deeply felt sense of being a man or woman, both or neither.
  • A person’s gender identity may or may not align with the gender typically associated with their sex.”

School boards define terms differently

  • Researchers have identified that secular boards across Ontario define gender identity and gender expression differently from one another.
  • Some school boards now define gender identity as something everyone has.

Data collection shifts away from sex towards gender

  • A shift away from sex and towards gender (identity) has occurred in data collection practices at the federal government level.
  • In 2018, the Treasury Board of Canada Secretariat and the Department of Justice Canada recommended “ways to modernize how the Government of Canada handles information on sex and gender.” They recommended that “departments and agencies should collect or display gender information by default, unless sex information is specifically needed.” They used “sex” to refer to biological characteristics, and “gender” to refer to a social and personal identity.

Open discussions are overdue


As Canadian society shifts to accommodate the legal recognition of gender diversity, there will be tensions. Ultimately, courts will be tasked with deciding how some of those tensions are resolved, when sex, gender identity and gender expression are all protected in human rights laws. In the meantime, as a society, we need to openly and transparently grapple with some increasingly important questions:
First, how will foundational concepts such as sex, gender identity and gender expression be defined and given effect in education, law, public policy and beyond?
Second, how will tensions between experiences, interests and rights associated with sex and those associated with gender identity and/or gender expression be resolved?
Third, who is best placed to decide how these questions are answered in education, law, public policy and beyond?
Everyone who may be impacted by the answers to these questions should be included in the conversation.
Debra M Haak receives funding from the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council, the Canadian Bar Association Law for the Future Fund, and the Queen's University Faculty Association Fund for Scholarly Research.

EQS-News: Lenzing presents innovative concept combining sustainable glacier protection and circularity for textiles

Retrieved on: 
星期三, 四月 10, 2024

Lenzing – The Lenzing Group, a leading supplier of regenerated cellulose for the textile and nonwovens industries, has created a unique, innovative concept that contributes to the sustainable protection of our glaciers while inspiring collective action for sustainable practices and a circular economy in the nonwovens and textile value chain.

Key Points: 
  • Lenzing – The Lenzing Group, a leading supplier of regenerated cellulose for the textile and nonwovens industries, has created a unique, innovative concept that contributes to the sustainable protection of our glaciers while inspiring collective action for sustainable practices and a circular economy in the nonwovens and textile value chain.
  • [2]
    The covering of a small area with the new material made from LENZING™ fibers was tested for the first time during a field test on the Stubai Glacier.
  • This was confirmed in a study conducted by the University of Innsbruck and the Austrian glacier lift operators on the Stubai Glacier in Tyrol (Austria).
  • Lenzing takes this pioneering innovation project as an opportunity to inspire collaborative action towards sustainable practices and circularity in the textile value chain.

Taking stock of existing barriers to sexual and reproductive health of girls and women in SSA and how collaboration and innovation can help shape the future

Retrieved on: 
星期三, 四月 10, 2024

For years, women and girls have been failed by a fragmented, under-resourced health system that is not built to meet their sexual and reproductive health needs.

Key Points: 
  • For years, women and girls have been failed by a fragmented, under-resourced health system that is not built to meet their sexual and reproductive health needs.
  • Coupled with HIV, complications during pregnancy and childbirth are the leading cause of death for young women aged 15-19 years.
  • "Tiko" which provides access to free reproductive health services that can change the course of many lives offering youth-friendly care and comprehensive information.
  • Achieving universal access to sexual and reproductive health and rights by 2030 will require close collaboration by stakeholders in developing innovative solutions that can dismantle barriers to access among women and girls.

The National Anti-Corruption Commission Thailand joins forces with international agencies to focus on preventing and suppressing transnational corruption

Retrieved on: 
星期三, 四月 10, 2024

BANGKOK, THAILAND - Media OutReach Newswire - 25 March 2024 - As emerging with rapid digitalization that paves the way for transnational corruption, the National Anti-Corruption Commission (NACC), Thailand further tightened its collaboration with international organizations in tackling new tactics and complicated illicit activities in accordance with global standards. The NACC's Secretary-General, Mr. Niwatchai Kasemmongkol recently met with representatives of the Nordic Police Liaison Office, led by Mr. Carsten Andersen, Assistant Attache/Liaison Officer, Nordic Police Affairs Department at the Danish Embassy, Thailand and Ms. Jane Ohlsson, Assistant Ambassador/Coordinating Officer for Police Affairs in the Nordic Countries at the Swedish Embassy, Thailand, along with NACC's executives and representatives from the Bureau of International Corruption Affairs and Cases, and the Bureau of Investigation and Special Affairs to enhance cooperation between the NACC enforcement agencies in combating transnational corruption. "Current corruption problems are not limited to any one country. But it has developed into a transnational crime, which affects all countries around the world. Therefore, cooperation between each other in various forms, both bilateral and multilateral is considered an important mechanism for effectively preventing transnational corruption of all kinds," said the NACC secretary-general. He further elaborated that the NACC has collaboration with enforcement agencies from the Nordic countries in both bilateral and multilateral. It has a memorandum of understanding between each other to exchange legal information, coordinate cases, as well as academic cooperation in particular, the sharing of knowledge and anti-corruption practices which is beneficial to raising the level of the Corruption Perceptions Index (CPI) of Thailand. This tie collaboration will help promote the prevention and suppression of corruption in Thailand more effectively. Furthermore, under the cooperation, both sides discussed and exchanged information on international cooperation in criminal matters related to corruption cases between Thailand and the Nordic countries. Denmark has expressed great interest in the NACC's corruption prosecutions and is willing to cooperate in solving transnational corruption cases, while also exchanging information that is beneficial to the fight against corruption. Mr. Niwatchai concluded that the NACC has given great importance to strengthening and expanding the network of cooperation with law enforcement agencies of various countries to deal with transnational corruption continuously. Presently, the NACC, in Thailand has made memoranda of understanding with 25 law enforcement agencies and international organizations, including nine ASEAN countries, the Ministry of Supervision of China, the Independent Authority against Corruption of Mongolia, the Anti-Corruption Commission of Bhutan, the Independent Commission Against Corruption of Australia, the Oversight and Anti-Corruption Authority of Saudi Arabia, the Police Presidium of the Czech Republic, Federal Ministry of the Interior of Austria, Investigative Committee of the Russian Federation, International Department of the National Crime Agency of the United Kingdom, and Office of the Comptroller General of Brazil, as well as World Bank, United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC), International Anti-Corruption Academy (IACA), Basel Institute on Governance, United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) and the UN International Organization for Migration (IOM). ----------------------------------------- *This exclusive interview translation is funded by the National Anti-Corruption Fund (NACF). Hashtag: #IntegrityWay #AntiCorruption #ZeroCorruption #NACC #NACF

Key Points: 
  • Therefore, cooperation between each other in various forms, both bilateral and multilateral is considered an important mechanism for effectively preventing transnational corruption of all kinds," said the NACC secretary-general.
  • He further elaborated that the NACC has collaboration with enforcement agencies from the Nordic countries in both bilateral and multilateral.
  • Furthermore, under the cooperation, both sides discussed and exchanged information on international cooperation in criminal matters related to corruption cases between Thailand and the Nordic countries.
  • The National Anti-Corruption Commission (NACC) is a constitutional independent organization and supervised by nine commissioners selected from various professions.

EQS-News: SIBUR attends Geneva roundtable, discusses projects to reduce plastic pollution

Retrieved on: 
星期三, 四月 10, 2024

Under its Vivilen brand, SIBUR produces a range of polymers containing recycled plastic for various applications: food (rPET), non-food (rPO) and home decor (rPS).

Key Points: 
  • Under its Vivilen brand, SIBUR produces a range of polymers containing recycled plastic for various applications: food (rPET), non-food (rPO) and home decor (rPS).
  • SIBUR is implementing a number of plastic collection and recycling projects in collaboration with various partners in its regions of operations.
  • According to the Russian Carbon Unit Registry, SIBUR has one of the largest portfolios of climate projects among the Russian companies.
  • SIBUR’s climate projects are set to reduce CO2 emissions by over 6 million tons by the end of 2032.

EQS-News: Tony Elumelu Foundation Announces 10th Cohort of Entrepreneurship Programme – 20,000 Entrepreneurs Funded Across Africa

Retrieved on: 
星期三, 四月 10, 2024

The Tony Elumelu Foundation (TEF), the leading philanthropy empowering young African entrepreneurs from all 54 African countries, has announced the successful entrepreneurs in its tenth selection for the TEF Entrepreneurship Programme.

Key Points: 
  • The Tony Elumelu Foundation (TEF), the leading philanthropy empowering young African entrepreneurs from all 54 African countries, has announced the successful entrepreneurs in its tenth selection for the TEF Entrepreneurship Programme.
  • The Tony Elumelu Foundation has disbursed US$100,000,000 directly to young African entrepreneurs, who have created over 400,000 direct and indirect jobs, contributing significantly to Africa's economic growth and development.
  • Since inception in 2010, the Tony Elumelu Foundation has pioneered an innovative approach to seeding, capacitising and networking young entrepreneurs across Africa.
  • To learn more about the Tony Elumelu Foundation Entrepreneurship Programme "Decade of Impact" please see here ( https://apo-opa.co/3IULYeS ).