Old Oak Common

How HS2 caused the UK to lose focus on 'levelling up' during years of high-speed rail delays

Retrieved on: 
Jeudi, septembre 28, 2023

Pressure on the UK government to confirm its plans for the controversial HS2 high-speed rail project is growing as the Conservative party prepares for its annual conference.

Key Points: 
  • Pressure on the UK government to confirm its plans for the controversial HS2 high-speed rail project is growing as the Conservative party prepares for its annual conference.
  • Much of the country is keen to hear about the fate of HS2.
  • The UK’s prime minister, Rishi Sunak, and chancellor, Jeremy Hunt, are weighing up the rising costs versus the benefits of HS2.

The rising costs of HS2

    • Over the decade since 2013, when construction commenced on the first phase of HS2, it has come under regular scrutiny because of rising costs.
    • At £300 million per mile, this is considerably higher than typical costs for constructing high-speed rail in Europe, according to analysis by The Times.
    • With an estimated cost of £37.5 billion in 2013 (at 2009 prices), HS2 represented considerable public investment to achieve what’s now commonly referred to as “levelling up”.
    • Government support for HS2 to achieve wealth creation outside the capital continued, however.
    • The David Cameron-led government supposedly saw HS2 as a “counterbalance” to extreme “local austerity”.

Unachievable

    • According to leaked analysis carried out by the DfT last year, increasing costs means HS2 will “deliver just 90 pence in economic benefit for every £1 it costs”.
    • But these links could be built faster and cheaper than HS2.

Former HS2 Chairman and Transport Minister questioned by Committee

Retrieved on: 
Mardi, janvier 22, 2019

The Economic Affairs Committee takes evidence on Tuesday 22 January 2019 at 3.35pm

Key Points: 
  • The Economic Affairs Committee follows up on its inquiry, The Economic Case for HS2, in a one-off session with Sir Terry Morgan, recently resigned Chairman of HS2 and Crossrail, and Nusrat Ghani MP, Parliamentary Under Secretary of State for Transport.
  • Would a London terminus at Old Oak Common rather than Euston really save 8 billion on the cost of HS2?
  • Is the recent reduction in the growth in demand for long-distance rail travel a concern for the business case for HS2?
  • Is it right that HS2 is being prioritised over improvements to local and regional services in the north of England?

Former HS2 Chairman and Transport Minister questioned by Committee

Retrieved on: 
Mardi, janvier 22, 2019

The Economic Affairs Committee takes evidence on Tuesday 22 January 2019 at 3.35pm

Key Points: 
  • The Economic Affairs Committee follows up on its inquiry, The Economic Case for HS2, in a one-off session with Sir Terry Morgan, recently resigned Chairman of HS2 and Crossrail, and Nusrat Ghani MP, Parliamentary Under Secretary of State for Transport.
  • Would a London terminus at Old Oak Common rather than Euston really save 8 billion on the cost of HS2?
  • Is the recent reduction in the growth in demand for long-distance rail travel a concern for the business case for HS2?
  • Is it right that HS2 is being prioritised over improvements to local and regional services in the north of England?