Three Mile Island Nuclear Generating Station

The nuclear arms race's legacy at home: Toxic contamination, staggering cleanup costs and a culture of government secrecy

Retrieved on: 
星期二, 八月 1, 2023

It initiated a global arms race that threatens the survival of humanity and the planet as we know it.

Key Points: 
  • It initiated a global arms race that threatens the survival of humanity and the planet as we know it.
  • It also led to widespread public health and environmental damage from nuclear weapons production and testing.
  • As a researcher examining communication in science, technology, energy and environmental contexts, I’ve studied these legacies of nuclear weapons production.
  • Total cleanup costs are projected to reach up to US$640 billion, and the job won’t be completed for decades, if ever.

Victims of nuclear tests

    • Nuclear weapons production and testing have harmed public health and the environment in multiple ways.
    • So far, they have not been included in the federal program to compensate uranium miners and “downwinders” who developed radiation-linked illnesses after exposure to later atmospheric nuclear tests.
    • The largest above-ground U.S. tests, along with tests conducted underwater, took place in the Pacific islands.
    • Estimating how many people have suffered health effects from these tests is notoriously difficult.

Polluted soil and water

    • Starting in 1944, workers at the remote site in eastern Washington state irradiated uranium fuel in reactors and then dissolved it in acid to extract its plutonium content.
    • Hanford’s nine reactors, located along the Columbia River to provide a source of cooling water, discharged water contaminated with radioactive and hazardous chemicals into the river through 1987, when the last operating reactor was shut down.
    • Extracting plutonium from the irradiated fuel, an activity called reprocessing, generated 56 million gallons of liquid waste laced with radioactive and chemical poisons.
    • The wastes were stored in underground tanks designed to last 25 years, based on an assumption that a disposal solution would be developed later.

A culture of secrecy

    • As the movie “Oppenheimer” shows, government secrecy has shrouded nuclear weapons activities from their inception.
    • But as I’ve argued previously, the principle of secrecy quickly expanded more broadly.
    • Initially, strict secrecy – reinforced by the region’s economic dependence on the Hanford site – made it hard for concerned citizens to get information.

Cautionary legacies

    • As Nolan’s film recounts, J. Robert Oppenheimer and many other Manhattan Project scientists had deep concerns about how their work might create unprecedented dangers.
    • Looking at the legacies of the Trinity test, I wonder whether any of them imagined the scale and scope of those outcomes.

Dutton wants Australia to join the "nuclear renaissance" – but this dream has failed before

Retrieved on: 
星期三, 七月 12, 2023

Last week, opposition leader Peter Dutton called for Australia to join what he dubbed the “international nuclear energy renaissance”.

Key Points: 
  • Last week, opposition leader Peter Dutton called for Australia to join what he dubbed the “international nuclear energy renaissance”.
  • The same phrase was used 20 years ago to describe plans for a massive expansion of nuclear.
  • New Generation III plants would be safer and more efficient than the Generation II plants built in the 1970s and 1980s.

The nuclear renaissance that wasn’t

    • Early in the 21st century, the outlook for nuclear energy seemed more promising than it had in years.
    • The time seemed right for a nuclear renaissance – especially in the United States.
    • Between 2007 and 2009, 13 companies applied for construction and operating licenses to build 31 new nuclear power reactors.
    • China has built a trickle of new nuclear plants, commissioning three or four a year over the last decade.

Nuclear falls short on cost, not politics

    • Despite the claims of some nuclear advocates, the renaissance in the 2000s did not fall short because of political resistance.
    • And, unlike in the 1970s where intense anti-nuclear sentiment was tied to fears of nuclear war, environmentalists in the 2000s had refocused on the need to stop burning carbon-based fuels.
    • Governments looking at nuclear saw the cost and time over-runs and decided it wasn’t worth it.
    • In Australia, the writing was on the wall by 2007, when an inquiry found new nuclear power would struggle to compete with either coal or renewables.

Could it be different this time?

    • Advocates hope the efficiency of factory production will offset the lower efficiency associated with smaller capacity.
    • Ironically, off-site mass production and modular installation is the basis of the success of solar and wind.
    • Like all small modular reactor designs, the VOYGR has yet to be produced and the US company has no firm orders.
    • Read more:
      If the opposition wants a mature discussion about nuclear energy, start with a carbon price.

A combination of social, organizational and technical factors caused the Titan's implosion

Retrieved on: 
星期四, 七月 6, 2023

But perhaps the OceanGate Titan submersible craft was doomed from the start.

Key Points: 
  • But perhaps the OceanGate Titan submersible craft was doomed from the start.
  • Given the disaster, it is surprising that the advertising web pages for future Titanic excursions have not yet been taken down.
  • Perhaps, it is reflective of a rapidly evolving situation with a company in crisis.

Reasons for failure

    • Concepts explaining the Titan’s failure can be traced back to ideas developed 45 years ago.
    • Barry Turner, an organizational sociologist and safety pioneer, studied long-forgotten disasters.

Normal accidents

    • An accident, then, could be considered an inevitable — normal — outcome.
    • Perrow sought to establish a basis for understanding why accidents will happen involving high-risk systems that someone has decided we cannot live without.
    • Accidents due to manned exploration of a treacherous 111-year-old shipwreck site, while tragic, are limited to direct participants.

High-reliability organizations

    • Dangers of normal accidents were balanced against the safety culture of high-reliability organizations.
    • In supporting the safe management of complex technologies, high-reliability organizations emerged.
    • Notwithstanding rare exceptions resulting in disasters like Chernobyl or Fukushima, nuclear power plant operators are high-reliability organizations.

Acknowledging complexity

    • They accept that the tasks at hand are complex, with a real potential to fail in new unexpected ways.
    • Photographs of the interior of the ill-fated Titan submersible show bare walls with no resemblance to a stereotypical cockpit with its bells and whistles.

A wake-up call

    • If not doing so at present, these companies should mimic the organizational culture of high-reliability organizations.
    • Read more:
      What was the 'catastrophic implosion' of the Titan submersible?

GSE Announces the Appointment of Thomas J. Dougherty to the Board of Directors

Retrieved on: 
星期二, 三月 1, 2022

"We are excited to welcome Tom as a new independent director to the GSE board.

Key Points: 
  • "We are excited to welcome Tom as a new independent director to the GSE board.
  • We are thrilled to have Tom as part of the team," said Kyle Loudermilk, President and CEO, GSE Solutions.
  • Mr. Thomas J. Dougherty, commented, "I am very pleased to join the board of directors of GSE.
  • GSE is proven, with over four decades of experience, more than 1,100 installations, and hundreds of customers in over 50 countries spanning the globe.

EnergySolutions and FirstEnergy Finalize Sale of Three Mile Island Unit-2 Nuclear Power Plant (TMI-2)

Retrieved on: 
星期五, 十二月 18, 2020

SALT LAKE CITY, Dec. 18, 2020 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) -- EnergySolutions announced today that it has completed the nearly two-year process for its EnergySolutions subsidiary, TMI-2 Solutions, to acquire the Three Mile Island Unit-2 Nuclear Power Plant (TMI-2), from subsidiaries of FirstEnergy Corp.

Key Points: 
  • SALT LAKE CITY, Dec. 18, 2020 (GLOBE NEWSWIRE) -- EnergySolutions announced today that it has completed the nearly two-year process for its EnergySolutions subsidiary, TMI-2 Solutions, to acquire the Three Mile Island Unit-2 Nuclear Power Plant (TMI-2), from subsidiaries of FirstEnergy Corp.
  • The purpose of this sale is to complete the decommissioning process of the facility, located in Londonderry Township, Pennsylvania.
  • This is a major step forward in the United States when it comes to decommissioning shut down nuclear power plants, stated Ken Robuck, President and CEO of EnergySolutions.
  • 99% of the damaged core was removed from the plant, packaged and relocated to a storage facility at Idaho National Laboratory (INL).

Pennsylvania AFL-CIO Disappointed With the Closure of Three Mile Island

Retrieved on: 
星期三, 五月 8, 2019

HARRISBURG, Pa., May 8, 2019 /PRNewswire/ --Today, Exelon Generation announced the Closure of Three Mile Island on September 30, 2019.

Key Points: 
  • HARRISBURG, Pa., May 8, 2019 /PRNewswire/ --Today, Exelon Generation announced the Closure of Three Mile Island on September 30, 2019.
  • On behalf of the more than 700,000 union members in Pennsylvania, the officers of the Pennsylvania AFL-CIO, President Rick Bloomingdale and Secretary-Treasurer Frank Snyder have issued the following joint statement:
    "We are deeply disappointed by Exelon Generation's decision to close Three Mile Island and eliminate hundreds of jobs in central Pennsylvania.
  • We hope lawmakers will find a renewed sense of urgency and try one more time to maintain our diverse energy portfolio.
  • Three Mile Island was built with union labor, is operated by union labor, and is maintained by union labor.

Three Mile Island Unit 1 to Shut Down by September 30, 2019

Retrieved on: 
星期三, 五月 8, 2019

Exelon Generation announced today that Three Mile Island Generating Station Unit 1 (TMI) will shut down by Sept. 30, 2019, as previously announced in May 2017.

Key Points: 
  • Exelon Generation announced today that Three Mile Island Generating Station Unit 1 (TMI) will shut down by Sept. 30, 2019, as previously announced in May 2017.
  • I want to thank the hundreds of men and women who will continue to safely operate TMI through September.
  • We will continue to work with the legislature and all stakeholders to enact policies that will secure a clean energy future for all Pennsylvanians.
  • Follow Exelon Generation on Twitter @ExelonGen , view the Exelon Generation YouTube channel , and visit http://www.exeloncorp.com/companies/exelon-generation .