World

The world's most powerful democracies were built on the suffering of others

Retrieved on: 
Monday, July 31, 2023

Democracy is supposed to base a state’s legitimacy in its accountability to its people.

Key Points: 
  • Democracy is supposed to base a state’s legitimacy in its accountability to its people.
  • But it’s clear the U.S. is no longer a credible champion for, or exemplar of, democracy.
  • In fact, it has a long history of overthrowing and undermining democracies abroad.

A troubled record with democracy

    • Barack Obama’s administration, for example, greenlit the military coup that overthrew Egypt’s democracy and ended the Arab Spring uprisings in 2013.
    • It has made it clear that being authoritarian does not impede any country from joining its coalition against China.
    • The U.S. itself is a failing democracy — or perhaps a better description is a plutocracy with democratic embellishments.
    • In 2021, only 50 per cent of Americans said they believed they live in a democracy.

Western democracy’s grim origins

    • This is not the only way the concept of democracy has been misused by the United States and other western nations.
    • Many countries in the West provide their citizens with the highest living standards and freedoms in the world.
    • The western world’s tendency to see itself as the pinnacle of civilization and morality has been used to justify global domination and intervention in the rest of the world.
    • During the Second World War, Winston Churchill deliberately implemented policies that created and exacerbated the Bengal Famine that killed more than three million Indians.

Hiding the truth

    • Belgium hid the truth of King Leopold’s vicious exploitation of the Belgian Congo that involved the murder of 10 million people.
    • In the U.S., the political right’s campaign against critical race theory stifles the historical reality and legacy of American racism.
    • Most western states can only offer examples of democracy-building that have relied upon extreme military, political and social violence.
    • Western states argue that only democracies are legitimate states because they are supported by the consent of their citizens.

Chinese prosperity

    • This support may reflect, in part, China’s cultural and historical norms and experiences but it is mostly attributable to how much the lives of the Chinese people have improved.
    • The Chinese Communist Party (CCP) has overseen 40 years of economic growth and technological development unprecedented in world history.
    • Chinese GDP per capita increased from US$195 in 1980 to US$12,556 in 2021.

The oil industry has succumbed to a dangerous new climate denialism

Retrieved on: 
Monday, July 31, 2023

If we have not been warned of the dangers of climate change this summer, we never will be.

Key Points: 
  • If we have not been warned of the dangers of climate change this summer, we never will be.
  • Yet the oil and gas industry remains largely in denial.
  • However, only a tiny fraction of the industry, accounting for less than 5% of oil and gas output, has targets aligned with the IEA’s “net zero” requirements.

The new denialism

    • Typical of the new breed of climate denialism is a recent report by the Energy Policy Research Foundation (ERPF), a body funded by the US government and various undisclosed corporate interests and foundations.
    • It sees the IEA’s requirements as a “seal of approval … to block investment in oil and gas production by western companies”.
    • The report views meeting the targets as too costly, too harsh on poor countries and too bad for the energy security of the west.
    • This is where one problem caused by global warming leads to others, such as melting permafrost unleashing stores of methane.
    • Going back to our average SSC per tonne of US$240, that points to a social cost of US$126 per barrel.

How to respond

    • It is as if heatwaves, forest fires, flooding, rising sea levels and the demise of natural habitat caused by climate inaction were happening on another planet.
    • The IEA requirements for “net zero” are just one of the pathways towards meeting the Paris goal of 1.5℃ warming.
    • The sooner the industry starts facing up to the realities of climate change, the more chance it has to survive.
    • The companies and even countries that produce fossil fuels will have to face and pay the cost for the damage they cause.
    • Every Wednesday, The Conversation’s environment editor writes Imagine, a short email that goes a little deeper into just one climate issue.

Bangladesh is undertaking the world's largest resettlement programme – and the climate is making it harder

Retrieved on: 
Monday, July 31, 2023

The nation’s topography lays its citizens bare to cyclones, flash floods, erosion and drought – not to mention the significant socio-economic impact these bring.

Key Points: 
  • The nation’s topography lays its citizens bare to cyclones, flash floods, erosion and drought – not to mention the significant socio-economic impact these bring.
  • With the population expected to reach 220 million by then, that would equate to 6% being made homeless.
  • The Ashrayan programme, launched in 1997, seeks to build new homes for people who are homeless and landless.
  • I have found that when structures are built at speed, without the necessary support system in place, communities’ vulnerability to the climate crisis only increases.

What is an Ashrayan?

    • An Ashrayan comprises anything from a few dozen barrack houses to several hundred, depending on the land available and the scale of the site.
    • The standard house features two to three rooms, a kitchen, a toilet and a small veranda.
    • Joint ownership of the land can be awarded in the name of both the wife and husband.
    • Residents have access to technical training courses and micro-credit programmes, as well as community centres and prayer halls.
    • However, critics point to the project’s failure to take geographical specificities and cultural nuances into consideration when Ashrayans are built.
    • Moreover, when situated at a remote location, residents lose access to the socio-cultural networks that are key to rebuilding communities.

How do we keep women's football clean? Start paying players a fair wage

Retrieved on: 
Friday, July 28, 2023

The women’s Netball World Cup, which also took place in Australia that year, did not feature in its preparations because it was deemed “low risk”.

Key Points: 
  • The women’s Netball World Cup, which also took place in Australia that year, did not feature in its preparations because it was deemed “low risk”.
  • By the time the FIFA Women’s World Cup was held in France in 2019, however, the football governing body was not taking any chances.
  • Many of these competitions lack key integrity protections like bet monitoring and athlete education, making them vulnerable targets for match-fixers.

Pay disputes in women’s football

    • For this year’s World Cup, several members of the Nigerian women’s team, the Super Falcons, were contemplating a boycott of their first match due to a pay dispute.
    • Nigeria’s opponent in its opening game, Canada, was also involved in a pay dispute with its federation, as were Jamaica and South Africa.

Why collective bargaining agreements are key

    • It took another four years before the Professional Footballers Australia, the players’ union, and Football Australia were able to sign a new collective bargaining agreement, which would guarantee an equal split of all commercial revenue between the men’s and women’s national teams.
    • The union believes this won’t address the inequity created by FIFA, which it could right with a stroke of the pen.
    • They have particularly highlighted the need for union representation and collective bargaining agreements that guarantee minimum standards and pay.
    • If these recommendations are implemented internationally, it will go a long way to supporting the women’s game and strengthening integrity.

Oppenheimer’s warning lives on: international laws and treaties are failing to stop a new arms race

Retrieved on: 
Thursday, July 27, 2023

Bush spoke of a “peace dividend” that would see money saved from reduced defence budgets transferred into more socially productive enterprises.

Key Points: 
  • Bush spoke of a “peace dividend” that would see money saved from reduced defence budgets transferred into more socially productive enterprises.
  • Long-term benefits and rises in gross domestic product could have been substantial, according to modelling by the International Monetary Fund, especially for developing nations.
  • With Russia ($86.4 billion) and China ($292 billion), the top three spenders account for 56% of global defence spending.
  • Aside from the opportunity cost represented by these alarming figures, weak international law in crucial areas means current military spending is largely immune to effective regulation.

The new nuclear arms race

    • Although the world’s nuclear powers agree “a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought”, there are still about 12,500 nuclear warheads on the planet.
    • According to the United Nations’ disarmament chief, the risk of nuclear war is greater than at any time since the end of the Cold War.
    • Beyond the promise of non-proliferation, the other nuclear-armed countries are not subject to any other international controls, including relatively simple measures to prevent accidental nuclear war.

The threat of autonomous weaponry

    • AI is not without its benefits, but it also presents many risks when applied to weapons systems.
    • There have been numerous warnings from developers about the unforeseeable consequences and potential existential threat posed by true digital intelligence.
    • But despite at least a decade of negotiation and expert input, a treaty governing the development of “lethal autonomous weapons systems” remains elusive.

Plagues and pathogens

    • There are 51 known biosafety level-4 (BSL-4) labs in 27 countries – double the number that existed a decade ago.
    • Finally, there are fears the World Health Organization’s new pandemic preparedness treaty, based on lessons from the COVID-19 disaster, is being watered down.

Measles: it's not just London that's at risk of an outbreak – it's all of the UK

Retrieved on: 
Thursday, July 27, 2023

The UK lost its measles-free status in 2019, indicating that the measles virus was circulating and there was inadequate vaccination to prevent its spread.

Key Points: 
  • The UK lost its measles-free status in 2019, indicating that the measles virus was circulating and there was inadequate vaccination to prevent its spread.
  • The virus spreads like wildfire among the unvaccinated, as demonstrated recently when seven unvaccinated children at a nursery school in Stoke-on-Trent nursery caught the bug.
  • There are no specific drugs for measles, so treatment is to help relieve symptoms and address complications, such as bacterial infections.
  • This pattern is seen globally, with many countries yet to attain the levels of routine immunisation coverage they had pre-pandemic.
  • For MMR, a national catch-up campaign is under way, and many regions have set up measles-elimination groups.
  • If this work is successful, hopefully the UK will be able to regain its measles-free status.

Africa at the Netball World Cup: four teams are set to inspire the continent

Retrieved on: 
Thursday, July 27, 2023

It’s the largest women’s sporting event on the planet – and for the first time it’s being hosted in Africa.

Key Points: 
  • It’s the largest women’s sporting event on the planet – and for the first time it’s being hosted in Africa.
  • Four African teams have made the final 16 of the 2023 tournament, which takes place in Cape Town, South Africa from July 28 until 6 August.

How would you describe the state of the sport in Africa?

    • The tournament’s presence in South Africa reflects the growing popularity and development of netball in Africa.
    • While netball has historically been more prominent in countries with Commonwealth ties, its appeal has been spreading across the continent.

How do the four African teams rate?

    • The competitiveness of African teams in the World Cup has likely improved over the years due to the increasing interest in the sport and the investments made in player development.
    • Teams from South Africa, Malawi and Uganda have been particularly strong contenders and have the potential to cause upsets against more established netball nations.
    • Based on these rankings, most of the African teams should reach the top eight placements.
    • Netball South Africa has been making great strides in developing and growing the sport professionally across the country.

What’s the importance for South Africa of hosting the cup?

    • She contends that success for the South African team – called the Spar Proteas – in the global showpiece would benefit the country greatly.
    • This being the first time the tournament is held in Africa, it’s also expected to bring a new flavour to the event.
    • It demonstrates South Africa’s ability to organise and host major sporting events, boosting its reputation as a destination.

And the impact for Cape Town?

    • As the host city, Cape Town experiences direct benefits.
    • The city will witness an influx of visitors, athletes, officials and media, leading to increased economic activity.

What does this do for netball in Africa?

    • Sport and physical education promote and strengthen social cohesion among learners from various socio-economic and cultural backgrounds.
    • And platforms like this provide an opportunity for sporting talent to be unearthed and nurtured; today’s young participants are tomorrow’s sport stars.

Trapped in NATO antechamber, Kyiv eyes 'military Marshall plan'

Retrieved on: 
Thursday, July 27, 2023

How could NATO get this war-torn European country out of its never-ending “in between” position, a grey zone and a strategic no man’s land that have left it vulnerable to those who deny it the right to exist?

Key Points: 
  • How could NATO get this war-torn European country out of its never-ending “in between” position, a grey zone and a strategic no man’s land that have left it vulnerable to those who deny it the right to exist?
  • At the close of the meeting, it’s important o acknowledge that the circle has not been squared.

The dangers of a conditional accession

    • This is, of course, welcome and even the Henry Kissinger, a famous proponent of realpolitik who was long opposed to Ukraine’s membership, shifted views earlier this year.
    • However, US president Joe Biden cut the enthusiasm short: a “prematured” accession would thrust NATO into a direct military conflict with Russia, which sees the Alliance as an existential threat.
    • Volodymyr Zelensky himself admitted that his country could not join as long as the war was still being fought.
    • As Zelensky warned: “We must remember that every doubt we show here in Europe is a trench that Russia will definitely try to occupy.”

How to deal with the “interim” period?

    • This will be decisive to dissuade Russia from engaging into a new escalation and to place Ukraine in a strong negotiating position when time comes for a peace settlement.
    • The debate about “security guarantees” erupted right after the launch of the Russian “special operation”.
    • Since then, however, neutrality for Ukraine has been relegated to the dustbin of history.

A military ‘Marshall Plan’

    • This kind of military “Marshall Plan”, as Eric Ciaramella, senior fellow at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, coined it, would keep Ukraine under “qualitative military edge”, the technological and tactical advantage to deter and, if necessary, defeat a numerically superior adversary.
    • The “Kyiv Security Compact” draws its inspiration from the “hedgehog theory”, under which a state becomes so well armed that its enemies will not try to swallow it.
    • The European Union could follow this path, and complement the G7’s offer with its own set of assistance measures.
    • Jens Stoltenberg, the Secretary-General of the Atlantic Alliance, stated that Ukraine is “now closer to NATO than ever before”.
    • More realistically, one could say that the martyred country remains trapped in the antechamber of the new European security order.

Women's World Cup: five issues holding back the female game

Retrieved on: 
Wednesday, July 26, 2023

The 2023 Fifa Women’s World Cup is probably the most highly-anticipated women’s football tournament ever.

Key Points: 
  • The 2023 Fifa Women’s World Cup is probably the most highly-anticipated women’s football tournament ever.
  • But there are ongoing issues that continue to jeopardise the women’s game.

1. Players and teams are having to fight for fairness

    • Before the tournament began, key players from top teams such as France, Spain, Canada and Jamaica were protesting about poor support, resourcing and coaching by either refusing to play or openly criticising their federations and seeking advice from Fifpro, the international players union.
    • As we have seen in the first few days, this means that many of the key stories of the tournament so far have been about the drama that is happening off the pitch, rather than the dramatic performances on it.

2. Serious injuries are decimating squads

    • Many players will be missing during the World Cup due to a disproportionately high number of serious injuries that could have been prevented.
    • The notorious anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) tear (in the knee) and other serious injuries decimating squads have, in part, been connected to overly long studs (cleats) on football boots which are designed for men.

3. The European broadcasting deal came too late

    • The media broadcasting rights for five European nations, including England, were only agreed less than six weeks before the tournament began.
    • This fiasco arose from a blunder by Fifa, whose decision to decouple the men’s and women’s tournament broadcast rights was hyped to show the women’s game had “made it”.

4. Many teams have been poorly supported and prepared

    • Many national federations have failed to provide adequate support, facilities and investment to adequately prepare teams.
    • Coaching methods and management of some women’s teams have been heavily criticised, alongside cancellation of training camps and non-payment of players’ appearance fees.

5. Same old patronising marketing strategy

    • The marketing of the tournament has been underwhelming and over-reliant on conventional “inspiration” themes aimed at young girls – strategies that have little proven impact on participation and are often seen as patronising.
    • This strategy is not accurate, as it obscures the existing adult audience for women’s football.

Showing support

    • Being aware of the issues can help us look past the hype and be mindful that the game is still in a precarious position.
    • Join in the social pressure campaign to get proper support for the women’s game.
    • Cut through the noise with a carefully curated selection of the latest releases, live events and exhibitions, straight to your inbox every fortnight,
      on Fridays.

Eskom and South Africa's energy crisis: De Ruyter book strikes a chord but falls flat on economic fixes

Retrieved on: 
Wednesday, July 26, 2023

Andre de Ruyter’s book Truth to Power is not the first exposé of the country’s political and economic woes under the African National Congress.

Key Points: 
  • Andre de Ruyter’s book Truth to Power is not the first exposé of the country’s political and economic woes under the African National Congress.
  • But it strikes a sensitive chord because of the impact of recurring power cuts on the economy and daily life, a crisis De Ruyter was hired to deal with.
  • Beyond his description of Eskom’s corruption and ineptitude is a subtler message that is equally disturbing.
  • It’s De Ruyter’s prescription to end the state’s involvement in the economy, which he sees as a major obstacle to economic growth.
  • Botswana’s post-colonial experience, discussed in my 1999 book, is most relevant to South Africa.

De Ruyter’s key claims

    • Many were not only ill-equipped for their jobs but sought to profit from their assignments through irregularities.
    • Second is a coalition of actors he calls the “coal mafia” in control of coal supply to Eskom.
    • Read more:
      Corruption in South Africa: former CEO's explosive book exposes how state power utility was destroyed

      Fourth, De Ruyter claims the ANC government failed to retain experienced white engineers.

    • In fact, some of the leaders flouted the ethical principles of the ANC itself by joining the ultra wealthy as inequality in the country deepened.

Neo-liberalism will not deliver

    • The beneficiaries of racist policies and the ANC’s neo-liberalism would be put on steroids.
    • His remedies are based on the policies the World Bank imposed on the rest of Africa in 1981, policies that devastated the continent.
    • He forgets that past segregationist policies gave nearly 87% of the land to white South Africans and heavily subsidised their education.

What went wrong with the ANC government?

    • One of the most precious assets the ANC brought into power in 1994 was the trust of the majority of citizens.
    • But successive ANC administrations, particularly since 2004, betrayed the trust of the majority in three ways.
    • Third, the moral decline of the ANC leadership most cruelly exposed by the Marikana massacre and state capture underscored the party’s impotence.

Seeing beyond the nightmare


    It is widely acknowledged that neo-liberal policies and corruption are companions in the contemporary developing world. Thus, what South Africa needs is not an extreme version of neo-liberalism, but a new social pact that creates productive jobs and achieves transformative social justice. Only then can South Africa hope for an African renaissance.