Ukraine war: what international law says about the Russians fighting against their own country
Retrieved on:
Thursday, June 15, 2023
Freedom, RVC, UAF, Second Boer War, World war, Freedom of Russia Legion, IHL, Peninsular War, Military, Method, Farmer, Hague Conventions of 1899 and 1907, Prisoner, Convention, Russian Volunteer Corps, Conduct, International Legion of Territorial Defence of Ukraine, POW, Third Geneva Convention, Soil, Torture, Foreign legion, Risk, Boers, FRL, Franco-Prussian War, Military Music Department of the General Staff of the Ukrainian Armed Forces, Article One, Territorial Defense, International law, Prisoner of war, International Legion, Tourism, Arms industry, Dam, Drug, Management, Medical device, Maquis
Ground raids in the Belgorod region of Russia, adjacent to the north-eastern frontier of Ukraine, appear to have upped the ante.
Key Points:
- Ground raids in the Belgorod region of Russia, adjacent to the north-eastern frontier of Ukraine, appear to have upped the ante.
- It creates legal complications in international humanitarian law (IHL) that will be difficult to untangle unless responsibility for the operations can be definitively attributed.
Who is involved
- The incursions have been carried out, according to Ukrainian officials, by two separate groups of Russian citizens.
- These are the Freedom of Russia Legion (FRL) and the Russian Volunteer Corps (RVC).
- Its status is unclear when it comes to the group’s relationship with Ukraine’s military command and control.
- The answers to these questions determine whether captured fighters are protected under IHL, and who will be held accountable for their actions.
Irregular fighters and international law
- The participation of irregular units in armed conflict has been a persistent feature of warfare since at least the Peninsular War (1808-1814).
- The development of international law to reflect this reality of modern warfare was further spurred by the French use of francs-tireurs (literally, “free-shooters”) in occupied areas of north-eastern France during the Franco-Prussian war (1870-1871).
- In the second Anglo-Boer war (1899-1902), meanwhile, the entire army of the Boer republics consisted of irregular farmers who were mobilised into kommandos to resist the British invasion.
- This defines entitlement after capture to the rights and protections of prisoners of war (POWs).
- A notable feature of that conflict had been the activities of armed resistance movements in occupied territory.
- And if the FRL has been incorporated into the Ukrainian Foreign Legion, as has been reported, its fighters should be considered part of the Ukrainian armed forces.
- Because they come under the IHL definition of combatants, they should be protected from being treated as saboteurs after capture, which carries a heavy penalty under Russian law.