SNL

• An analysis based on a large
  bank-firm panel

  No 2902

  Disclaimer: This paper should not be reported as representing the views of the European Central Bank
  (ECB).

• We find
  that weaker capitalised banks adjust their credit standards more than healthier banks, especially for
  firms with a higher default risk.
• Here we find t hat w eaker b anks r espond m ore f orcefully by
  tightening their credit standards more than better capitalised banks.
• On the contrary, weaker banks
  may be more prone to adopt looser credit standards, with the aim of increasing their revenues.
• To answer these questions, we analyse the determinants of banks? credit standards, i.e., their internal
  guidelines or loan approval criteria applied when deciding on granting credit.
• 2 Altavilla

  ECB Working Paper Series No 2902

  2

  area banks tighten their credit standards more when linked to riskier firms, measured via firms? leverage
  and default risk.

• We assess how euro area banks adjusted their credit standards in response to
  the negative COVID-19 pandemic shock, after accounting for government support measures.
• When deciding on their credit standards, banks assess risks
  based on both their own loss absorption capacity and the credit risk of their borrowers.
• On the contrary,
  weaker banks may be more prone to adopt looser credit standards, with the aim of increasing their
  revenues.
• We provide evidence that
  euro area banks tighten their credit standards more when linked to riskier firms, measured via firms?
  leverage and default risk based on the Altman Z-score.
• In
  addition, they focus on a different research question and use data from the IBLS only as a control.
• ECB Working Paper Series No 2902

  5

  capital position implies less tightening of lending criteria, possibly reflecting the fact that banks can
  afford to adjust their credit standards more moderately.

• Based on our results, this implies a stronger deterioration of their lending conditions compared
  with less vulnerable firms.
• We assess how euro area banks adjusted their credit standards in response to
  the negative COVID-19 pandemic shock, after accounting for government support measures.
• This is in line with the role of government support
  measures such as loan guarantees mitigating banks? exposure to firms? credit risks as they shield banks
  from firms? increased credit risks.
• 2

  Related literature

  Our paper is closely related to studies analysing credit supply based on BLS indicators and the impact
  of monetary policy shocks on bank lending conditions in the euro area.

• Hempell and Kok (2010) disentangle
  pure loan supply based on the BLS factors and investigate the role played by such factors for loan growth.
• Several other studies link confidential individual BLS data with actual bank-level data, but not firm
  data, allowing an analysis of bank characteristics relevant for bank lending conditions.
• They find that a short-term interest rate shock decreases both loan supply
  and demand, but more for less healthy banks.
• Their findings are consistent with the results of our paper on the favourable impact of bank health on lending standards.
• Both papers tend to find no evidence of higher risk taking of banks as a result
  of accommodative monetary policy.
• More recent studies are based on
  confidential bank and firm-level data from national credit registers.
• (2012) who focus on the bank-firm-relationship in Spain, based on credit register data.
• Ferrero, Nobili, and Sene (2019) arrive at a corresponding conclusion on the risk-taking
  channel based on a confidential loan-level dataset of Italian banks.
• In another paper, Altavilla, Boucinha, and Bouscasse (2022)
  disentangle credit demand and supply based on euro area credit register data (AnaCredit) for the period
  of the pandemic.
• Our results emphasise the
  mitigating impact of government guarantees on a tightening of credit standards during the pandemic.
• This mitigating impact played a major role in loan demand and not credit supply being decisive for lending volumes during the pandemic.
• Based on their model, accommodative monetary policy is part of the optimal policy mix, combined with social insurance.
• To keep the wealth of information
  available in the BLS, we run our analysis at the quarterly frequency of the survey.
• of employees

  101.4

  2456.9

  2.0

  4.0

  12.0

  37.0

  116.0

  14944589

  Panel (a): Banks
  Credit standards

  Loan loss provisions
  Panel (b): Firms

  Notes: Descriptive statistics for the bank-firm sample included in the regression analysis.

• Specifically, a one
  standard deviation increase in the CET1 ratio leads to 0.2 standard deviations lower credit standards,
  i.e., easier credit standards.
• In their lending decisions, banks assess risks based on both their own
  loss absorption capacity and the credit risk of their borrowers.
• ?Credit supply and monetary policy: Identifying the bank balance-sheet channel with loan applications.? American Economic
  Review 102 (5):2301?2326.
• ?Hazardous times for monetary policy: What do twenty-three million bank loans say
  about the effects of monetary policy on credit risk-taking?? Econometrica 82 (2):463?505.
• ?The credit cycle and the business cycle: new findings using
  the loan officer opinion survey.? Journal of Money, Credit and Banking 38 (6):1575?1597.
• guarantees: proxy from BLS, bank level

  0

  .1

  .2

  .3

  .4

  Government guarantees exposure

  -.5

  -.25

  0

  .25

  .5

  Government guarantees exposure

  Notes: Based on results from columns (3) and (6) of Table 4.

• Emmy Award-winning producer and journalist Tanya McRae will host the event, and Super Bowl LVI Champion and 2021 Walter Payton NFL Man of the Year Andrew Whitworth and the Los Angeles Rams Foundation will receive awards for their commitment and contributions that support justice and opportunity for youth.
• Past honorees include Kiesha C. Nix of the LA Lakers Youth Foundation, Ed Magee of Fender Play Foundation, and Maggie Baird of Support + Feed.
• Gala to be hosted by Emmy Award-winning producer and Spectrum News journalist Tanya McRae.
• Super Bowl LVI Champion and 2021 Walter Payton NFL Man of the Year Andrew Whitworth and the Los Angeles Rams Foundation will receive awards for their commitment and contributions that support justice and opportunity for youth.

• 'Mistaken Identity' is the culmination of my efforts to be true to myself in the creative process.
• Paying homage to those I admire and who have supported me on my journey is a great point of reference in my recordings.
• Recorded in two sessions—in 2018 and 2021, pre- and post-pandemic—"Mistaken Identity" is something of a sampler platter that reintroduces Blake to the jazz-listening public.
• Ron Blake will be performing a CD release show at Dizzy's, New York City, on Wednesday 11/1 with Bobby Broom, guitar; Reuben Rogers, bass; and Kobie Watkins, drums.

• Those records cut right through the other stuff I was listening to: guitar bands with men mostly.
• Music that told stories full of detail and delivered with sadness and tenderness and anger.
• Read more:
  Sinéad O'Connor: a troubled soul with immense talent and unbowed spirit

A particular kind of passion

• Troy was the first single from the first album, but did not become a huge hit.
• I remember it
  Dublin in a rainstorm
  Sitting in a long grass in summer
  Keeping warm.
• Tender and lilting at the beginning with shades of traditional Irish folk singing, and then, out of the blue, shockingly angry.
• This seemed like serious, grown-up songwriting, full of a particular kind of passion.
• O'Connor’s ability to contrast the personal detail with big picture politics was second to none and such a fine feature of her songwriting.

Courage and insight

• She was so often dismissed by commentators as mad, rather than respected for her courage and insight.
• As we know now, she was completely right about the things she spoke up about.
• Her critique of religion and politics and her later explorations of Islam and Rastafarianism showed her seeking, questioning mind.