Institute

Bid-rigging is rife in Australian construction, but the process itself is partly to blame

Retrieved on: 
Wednesday, August 2, 2023

The Court ordered ARM Architecture to pay a penalty of $900,000 and Mr Allen to pay $75,000.

Key Points: 
  • The Court ordered ARM Architecture to pay a penalty of $900,000 and Mr Allen to pay $75,000.
  • I have lost my position, my reputation, and my involvement in a profession that I love.
  • He had followed it up with this second email:
    We have received very positive responses from Architectus and JWA.
  • We would greatly appreciate a short note from you to let us know of your intentions either way.`

The biggest fine for architects so far

    • Although colluding in bidding for contracts is rife in the construction industry and materials supply industries, this is the biggest fine so far for an individual professional services firm.
    • In Australia, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission managed to successfully prosecute Cement Australia Pty Ltd in 2017 for anti-competitive practices resulting in a fine of $20.6 million.

Fees used to be fixed

    • The Royal Institute of British Architects, founded in 1834, was set up primarily as a cartel to maintain a schedule of fees and prescribe educational standards for those who wanted to use the term “architect”.
    • Although fixed fees are likely to upset economists on principle, they have the advantage of not encouraging architects to shortcut their professional responsibilities in order to compete on price.
    • This might be why the law allows medical professionals, lawyers and pharmacists to set fees for their services.

Bidding processes convoluted

    • This two-stage process, devised by a project management firm, was self-defeating.
    • Charles Darwin University wanted a highly-awarded architect to deliver an iconic building, but much of the design ARM contributed has been lost.

Maybe there’s a better way

    • It ought to be possible for the client to nominate a reasonable fee, and then select consultants who will accept the nominated fee based purely on their merit.
    • Free-market economists might like to think about how much competitive tenders actually cost.

Ukraine war: after two months of slow progress the long-awaited counteroffensive is picking up speed. Why has it taken so long?

Retrieved on: 
Monday, July 31, 2023

Ukraine’s 2023 counteroffensive was the subject of speculation for months before it officially began at the beginning of June.

Key Points: 
  • Ukraine’s 2023 counteroffensive was the subject of speculation for months before it officially began at the beginning of June.
  • So far, only modest progress has been made and there have been concerns from Kyiv’s allies that Ukraine is making insufficient headway against entrenched Russian defences.
  • With the end of summer now fast approaching, it seems that a serious push is taking place.
  • But reports emerge daily to indicate that progress is being made in a number of areas.

Overcoming Russian defences

    • While Russian forces are reported to be disorganised and suffering low morale, they have the advantage of occupying well-prepared defensive positions, which will make them hard to dislodge.
    • They have been able to prepare many challenges, such as minefields that stretch for hundreds of kilometres.
    • While Ukraine possesses a highly mobile, well-trained and capable force, physical barriers of this nature are proving difficult to navigate.

Pragmatic approach

    • Heavy losses in early phases have already caused Ukraine to rethink its approach.
    • General Syrskyi, the architect of some of Ukraine’s biggest victories, stresses the importance of a cautious approach: “We’d like to get very fast results, but in reality, it’s practically impossible.” Likewise, Ukraine’s president, Volodymyr Zelensky, has stressed the importance of not expecting “Hollywood” style outcomes.
    • This is likely to frustrate key Nato allies, who are increasingly critical of the pace of advance.
    • Yet again, Ukrainian forces are pragmatic: “We can’t draw big conclusions yet,” a senior military officer told journalists on July 30.

More than a picture: how the work of documentary photographer Raphaela Rosella is defined by co-creation

Retrieved on: 
Friday, July 28, 2023

For 15 years, artist Raphaela Rosella and the women close to her have forged their own complex visual narratives, despite frequent interventions by the criminal justice system.

Key Points: 
  • For 15 years, artist Raphaela Rosella and the women close to her have forged their own complex visual narratives, despite frequent interventions by the criminal justice system.
  • Rosella is an Italian-Australian documentary artist devoted to long-term, socially engaged collaborative projects made with participants from Nimbin, Casino, Lismore and Moree in regional New South Wales.
  • This means active collaboration in making images and a body of work, as well as continually seeking consent if sharing it with an audience.

Welcomed into a home

    • Some of the audio-visual archive was produced by participants while imprisoned, in response to a legal system that confronted them at a young age.
    • The women see their collaborative work as a “site of resistance” where they can detach their identities from the procedures and labels imposed by bureaucracy.
    • Rather than granting sole storytelling agency to one artist or organisation, these women take a central role in communicating their own histories and perspectives.
    • The show feels like being welcomed into someone’s home: there are fabric curtains, handwritten cards, family photos, the reassuring sound of nearby voices.

Crucial questions

    • Many of the people whose lives we engage with in the show are Aboriginal, and all have been impacted by violence.
    • One participant, Tammara, was killed in 2020 after the pair had been working together for a decade.
    • Wall text and a small, handwritten note from mother to her newborn baby tell us that Rowrow is under prison guard.
    • As an audience, we are driven to ask questions.

Collaborative dialogue

    • Documentary photographers have historically sought to reveal problems and inequalities in the world, fuelled by a desire to provoke change.
    • Lewis Hine famously played a role in reforming child labour laws in the USA through his images of young children at work.
    • Rosella, by contrast, engages in a genuine collaborative dialogue.
    • You’ll Know It When You Feel It is at the Institute of Modern Art, Brisbane, until August 19.

Essop Pahad: a diligent communist driven by an optimistic vision of a non-racial South Africa

Retrieved on: 
Wednesday, July 26, 2023

Any examination of Pahad’s full political record will take you back to the heroic phases of South Africa’s liberation history, when prospects for a democratic South African government seemed very remote.

Key Points: 
  • Any examination of Pahad’s full political record will take you back to the heroic phases of South Africa’s liberation history, when prospects for a democratic South African government seemed very remote.
  • As a teenager in the 1950s he was busy in the Transvaal Indian Youth Congress.
  • This was the equivalent of the youth league of the liberation movement, the African National Congress (ANC), for Indian South Africans.
  • In my own research on the South African Communist Party’s history, groups like the Transvaal Indian Youth Congress were game-changers.

The early years

    • Pahad employed ANC leader Walter Sisulu, supporting his efforts to become an estate agent.
    • Both Essop and his younger brother Aziz did well enough to obtain entry to the University of the Witwatersrand.
    • The Transvaal Indian Youth Congress was led by party members and its political affiliations were very evident in its journal, New Youth.
    • Mbeki was then staying in Johannesburg, completing his A-levels through correspondence after expulsion from Lovedale College for leading a class boycott.

Exile years

    • Pahad would complete an MA and a doctorate at Sussex between 1965 and 1971, producing a workmanlike dissertation about the South African Indian Congresses.
    • Pahad’s most conspicuous activity during his exile was his deployment in Prague at the World Marxist Review; acknowledgement by the Communist Party of his status as a reliable theoretician.
    • He and Meg lived in Prague between 1975 and 1985, and their two daughters were born there, attending Czech schools.

Right-hand man

    • At that time Mbeki’s future succession to the presidency was uncertain and the party was one key constituency.
    • But it is true that Pahad’s subsequent political career would be defined by his status as Mbeki’s trusted friend, his best man as it were, a function he actually performed at Mbeki’s wedding in 1974.
    • So, during the presidency of Nelson Mandela (10 May 1994-16 June 1999) he served as Mbeki’s “parliamentary counsellor”.

Diligent

    • He surprised even his critics with the diligence with which he supported the offices placed under his authority as minister, for example urging municipalities to “mainstream” disability rights.
    • He had invited Ajay Gupta to join the International Marketing Council in 2000, an appointment that he subsequently regretted.

To reclaim downtowns from traffic, require developers to offer strategies for cutting car use

Retrieved on: 
Wednesday, July 26, 2023

Across the country, parking takes up an estimated 30% of space in cities.

Key Points: 
  • Across the country, parking takes up an estimated 30% of space in cities.
  • The dominance of parking has devastated once-vibrant downtowns by turning large areas into uninviting paved spaces that contribute to urban heating and stormwater runoff.
  • It has driven up housing costs, since developers pass on the cost of providing parking to tenants and homebuyers.
  • For decades, cities have required developers to provide a set number of parking spaces for their tenants or customers.

Eliminating parking requirements

    • This led to excess parking that is vastly underused, even in areas with perceived shortages.
    • Tony Jordan, president of the nonprofit Parking Reform Network, has argued that once cities stop mandating specific levels of private parking, leaders need to be more thoughtful about how they manage public curbside parking and spend the revenues that it generates.
    • Some communities have implemented maximum parking allowances to ensure that developers and their investors don’t add to the glut.

Reducing reliance on cars

    • Some local governments are now asking developers to help reduce overall traffic levels by investing in improvements like sidewalks, bike storage and transit passes.
    • It still leverages private investment to serve the public good but without a singular focus on parking.
    • That policy has now outlived the city’s minimum parking requirements, which Cambridge eliminated for all residential uses in 2022.

Lessons from Madison

    • We recently collaborated on a new transportation demand management program in Madison.
    • Scaling back planned parking can reduce the number of points they need to earn in the first place.
    • While parking is no longer required in many parts of Madison, this new policy adds a layer of accountability to ensure that developers provide access to multiple transportation options in environmentally responsible ways.

Where the government draws the line for Medicaid coverage leaves out many older Americans who may need help paying for medical and long-term care bills – new research

Retrieved on: 
Wednesday, July 26, 2023

The Research Brief is a short take about interesting academic work.The big ideaBased on a study we conducted, we determined that if strict eligibility rules for Medicaid were changed to help cover such people, from 700,000 to 11.5 million people over 65 would be newly eligible for the program.

Key Points: 


The Research Brief is a short take about interesting academic work.

The big idea

    • Based on a study we conducted, we determined that if strict eligibility rules for Medicaid were changed to help cover such people, from 700,000 to 11.5 million people over 65 would be newly eligible for the program.
    • Depending on which rules were changed, we would expect to see one of the following scenarios:


    Unless the government adopted the Elder Index approach, most of the additional enrollees in these scenarios would have poor health and few financial assets.

Why it matters

    • Low-income adults who are excluded from Medicaid under existing criteria also face high health care costs that contribute to their financial insecurity.
    • Researchers found that 1 in 5 Americans over 65 skipped, delayed or used less medical care or drugs because of financial constraints.
    • Increasing the number of low-income older people with both Medicaid and Medicare coverage would reduce their out-of-pocket health spending.

What still isn’t known

    • Increasing the number of older people with Medicaid coverage would require more government funding, although the degree of extra spending would depend on which rules the government would change.
    • Accurately estimating these costs and the potential benefits for families and communities that would come from these changes would require additional research.

Student number caps on 'rip-off degrees' overlook their potential benefits for social mobility

Retrieved on: 
Thursday, July 20, 2023

The intention of the government intervention is to ensure that students get appropriate value from their courses.

Key Points: 
  • The intention of the government intervention is to ensure that students get appropriate value from their courses.
  • It also intends to make sure taxpayers aren’t left to foot the bill when students don’t earn enough to repay all of their student loans.
  • But less-selective universities – and the courses they offer – play a significant role in driving social mobility and supporting the local economy.
  • Overall, a student from a low-income background is four times more likely to be socially mobile if they attend university.

Student outcomes

    • Universities are already regulated based on their student outcomes.
    • The OfS publishes data on these student outcomes.
    • The cap on student numbers for particular courses now planned by the government is an additional penalty.
    • Despite the fact that the highest earners subsidise those who do not fully repay their student loans, we end up with a workforce that is rich and varied in background and skills and diverse in its make up.

'Now I am become Death, the destroyer of worlds': who was atom bomb pioneer Robert Oppenheimer?

Retrieved on: 
Tuesday, July 18, 2023

Robert Oppenheimer is often placed next to Albert Einstein as the 20th century’s most famous physicist. He will forever be the “father of the atomic bomb” after the first nuclear weapon was successfully tested on July 16, 1945 in the New Mexican desert. The event brought to his mind words from a Hindu scripture: “Now I am become Death, the destroyer of worlds”.Who was Robert Oppenheimer?Two years later, he completed his PhD in physics at one of the world’s leading institutions for theoretical physics, the University of Göttingen, Germany.

Key Points: 


Robert Oppenheimer is often placed next to Albert Einstein as the 20th century’s most famous physicist. He will forever be the “father of the atomic bomb” after the first nuclear weapon was successfully tested on July 16, 1945 in the New Mexican desert. The event brought to his mind words from a Hindu scripture: “Now I am become Death, the destroyer of worlds”.

Who was Robert Oppenheimer?

    • Two years later, he completed his PhD in physics at one of the world’s leading institutions for theoretical physics, the University of Göttingen, Germany.
    • Throughout his life, Oppenheimer would be judged either as an aloof prodigy or an anxious narcissist.
    • Before the outbreak of the second world war, Oppenheimer worked at the University of California, Berkeley, and the California Institute of Technology.
    • His partner, Kitty Puening, was a left-leaning radical and their social circle included Communist Party members and activists.

The second world war

    • His ideas about chain reaction in an atomic bomb gained recognition among the US defence community.
    • His ability to master the large-scale workforce and channel their energy towards the needs of the project earned him respect.
    • He proved to be more than just an administrator by being involved in the interdisciplinary team across theoretical and experimental stages of the weapons development.

The nuclear test

    • On July 16, 1945 the nuclear test, code named Trinity, took place.
    • Shortly after the atomic bombs were dropped on the Japanese cities of Hiroshima and Nagasaki in August 1945, Oppenheimer confronted the US secretary of war, Henry Stimson, demanding that nuclear weapons were banned.
    • Truman’s rebuttal did not prevent Oppenheimer from advocating for the establishment of controls on the nuclear arms race.

Arms control

    • But his chief concern was the unavoidable arms race.
    • He advocated for the establishment of an international body that would control the development of nuclear energy and its usage.
    • Oppenheimer urged strongly for international arms control.
    • The investigation that followed in 1954 exposed Oppenheimer’s past communist ties and culminated in his security clearance being revoked.

McCarthyism and academic freedom

    • In the era of Joseph McCarthy’s witch-hunts, his fellow scientists considered Oppenheimer as a martyr of the cause of academic freedom.
    • He toured internationally with talks about the role of academic freedom unrestrained by political considerations.

Somaliland: Berbera city's growth is being held back by a power supply monopoly

Retrieved on: 
Sunday, July 9, 2023

Over the years, these revenues have mostly gone into the central state coffers, while the development of Berbera has been neglected.

Key Points: 
  • Over the years, these revenues have mostly gone into the central state coffers, while the development of Berbera has been neglected.
  • When we visited the city for our research project on port infrastructure, international politics, and everyday life, this neglect was immediately visible.
  • Physical and social infrastructure – ranging from roads, water and electricity to health and schooling – were lacking.
  • Lack of regulation, and collaboration between the government and private businesses have spawned a monopoly of energy provision in Berbera.

Berbera port and development

    • The neglect of Berbera city stands in stark contrast to the modern technologies and equipment at its port.
    • Since 2017 the port has been managed by the Dubai-based logistics giant DP World.
    • And a transport corridor that links the port with Ethiopia is nearly complete.
    • So far, only limited investments have been made into the generation of clean energy, among them a solar mini grid in Berbera, funded by the Abu Dhabi Fund for Development.

The privatisation of energy

    • The energy sector, for example, started with private business people who initially used generators for their own consumption.
    • The businesses eventually provided their neighbourhoods with excess energy.
    • At least four major energy suppliers are competing for customers in Somaliland’s capital city, Hargeisa.

Mini grid solar power plant

    • The Abu Dhabi Fund for Development, for example, provides financial and technical support for the transport corridor from Berbera to Ethiopia.
    • It has also initiated social projects for the urban poor in Berbera, like building schools and providing green and affordable energy.
    • It financed a 7MW solar power plant which was inaugurated in January 2021.
    • But immediately after the launch of the project, the Somaliland Ministry of Mines and Energy handed over the solar facility to Berbera Power House.
    • During the inauguration of the mini grid solar power plant, the finance minister proposed that electricity prices in Berbera would be reduced to US$0.1 per unit compared to US$0.6 per unit before the investment.

Ukraine recap: Yevgeny Prigozhin and the mystery of the mutiny that never was

Retrieved on: 
Thursday, July 6, 2023

But on June 24, at least some Russian troops moved much more rapidly toward their own capital.

Key Points: 
  • But on June 24, at least some Russian troops moved much more rapidly toward their own capital.
  • Barely had our ink dried when Prigozhin led 25,000 of his troops back into Russia.
  • Putin vowed a “harsh response” to Prigozhin and those who were joining the Wagner Group boss up the M4 highway towards Moscow.
  • Prigozhin, who apparently agreed to relocate to Belarus, seems to be free to move between the two countries with a degree of security.
  • Read more:
    Failed Wagner Group coup leaves Putin humiliated and Belarus dictator Lukashenko more secure – for now

Meanwhile in nearby Vilnius

    • Finland has successfully acceded to membership of the alliance, hugely extending Nato’s border with Russia.
    • But he may be mollified if the US changes its mind over the supply of F-16 fighter jets.
    • Read more:
      Nato: Vilnius summit will reflect fresh sense of purpose over Ukraine war – but hard questions remain over membership issues

Parallels with the past