Report Uses Weak Data and Methods to Promote School Choice
The report ranks states based on their expansion of market-oriented school policies such as vouchers, charters, homeschooling, and inter-district choice.
- The report ranks states based on their expansion of market-oriented school policies such as vouchers, charters, homeschooling, and inter-district choice.
- While repeatedly stating that their data and methods "cannot establish conclusively whether education freedom caused those changes," the authors also repeatedly trumpet the association teased out by their model and urge policymakers to embrace school choice policies.
- They also explain that the report, by ignoring relevant peer-reviewed research that has found negative consequences of school choice reforms, does not engage meaningfully with the larger body of research.
- Instead, the report uses such findings to buttress its concluding claim that a package of school choice reforms is desirable and beneficial.