After the Manitoba crash, Canada needs to rethink bus safety
The recent collision between a bus and a semi-truck near Carberry, Man., which killed 16 seniors, is the latest fatal incident to raise concerns about bus and road safety in Canada.
- The recent collision between a bus and a semi-truck near Carberry, Man., which killed 16 seniors, is the latest fatal incident to raise concerns about bus and road safety in Canada.
- The crash shares similarities to other fatal bus crashes like the 2018 Humboldt Broncos bus crash and the 2019 bus rollover on Vancouver Island.
Road transportation is a provincial responsibility
- When it comes to road transportation, Canada adheres to an archaic regulatory framework that can be traced all the way back to confederation.
- At the time, John A. Macdonald argued that roads should be a provincial responsibility with no federal involvement or guidance.
Improving road safety
- Improving road safety and standards should include developing national standards, guidance and dedicated funding sources (for example, gas tax) to support the construction and operation of road networks.
- In 2018, Canada ranked 12th compared to other member countries in the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development in terms of road safety.
Response to major road crashes
- This allows the TSB to investigate all matters related to these modes and to press all levels of government for change.
- The TSB has no role in investigating road crashes or bridge failures no matter how catastrophic.
- Best practices dictate that serious road crashes across the country be investigated by an independent body.
- For these reasons, we must demand that serious road crashes be subject to the same type of independent and transparent safety investigations that are routinely conducted in other modes.
Stalled progress
- The committee’s report contained nine important recommendations to improve bus passenger safety.
- Four years later, there has been little progress on the recommendations.
- The House of Commons needs to follow up on the recommendations and demand that regulatory changes be introduced to make bus travel safer.